Summary
What do they do? Transportation Alternatives organizes for safer walking, cycling and transit across New York City. This report includes its entire recipient, including Families for Safe Streets, research, membership and events. Safer streets could avert serious injuries, but this review cannot establish the health return from an additional unrestricted gift.
Why we’re interested in this organization:
Current campaigns organize around identifiable street-design decisions.
Original audits and tax reconciliations recover separately netted event costs.
The injury mechanism is more direct than assigning health value to petitions or cycling counts.
Our main reservations:
No evidence identifies how many additional corridor improvements an ordinary gift causes.
The DOT injury association is not a randomized estimate of future campaigns.
Public construction costs, travel changes and other portfolio effects may materially change total social value.
What do you get for your dollar? A reliable cost per DALY has not been established.
Additional corridor-equivalent years -> avoided fatal and nonfatal severe injuries -> finite discounted health.
1. What do they do?
Transportation Alternatives Inc., EIN 51-0186015, combines advocacy, organizing, research, membership and events. Families for Safe Streets is inside this recipient, not a second charity credited independently. Current work includes Central Harlem protected lanes, connected Brooklyn and Queens networks, speed-limit implementation and transit access. An ordinary gift supports this mixed portfolio, not a guaranteed lane project. Current campaigns Central Harlem proposal
2. Monitoring and information sharing
Measure additional or accelerated implementation, collision risk and finite health, rather than campaign participation. NYC DOT's 2005–2018 evaluation reports an 18.1% before/after reduction in killed-or-severely-injured road users across 146 protected-bike-lane treatments and 36.7 centerline miles. Selection of dangerous corridors, regression to the mean and concurrent changes matter; the association is not a randomized causal contrast or an estimate of TA's contribution. A historical scenario halves the association, but this does not establish donation-driven implementation. The 31st Street proposal reports 26 people killed or severely injured during 2021–2025, giving 5.2 annual events as a selected high-risk corridor anchor, not a representative mean for TA's campaigns. DOT evaluation 31st Street proposal
A useful recipient disclosure would list proposed, unsuccessful and implemented campaigns, prior city commitments, implementation dates, funding constraints and matched safety trends. Citywide improvements or income-group trends cannot identify TA's contribution. DOT equity analysis
3. Qualitative assessment
Protected street design has a plausible injury pathway, while public agencies retain legal, engineering and spending authority. Existing city projects, elected officials, other advocates and community demand remain in the counterfactual. Current Central Harlem organizing demonstrates an active opportunity, not a measured probability of success. The model represents four corridor-equivalent opportunities over an annual portfolio cycle, not four observed additional projects or credit for 31st Street itself.
The denominator includes only residents of the official 22-county New York–Newark–Jersey City MSA. A 95% resident share of the modeled injury benefit is an explicit judgment: city streets also serve tourists and commuters from outside this MSA. All five city boroughs are within scope; headquarters location alone is not the allocation method.
Fare, travel-cost and commute resource pathways are assessed unknown and potentially material, not zero or a90%-health finding.
4. What do you get for your dollar?
Household resources are assessed unknown and potentially material. The current unrestricted-gift clinical estimate remains unidentified, as in the original report; the historical conditional street-injury reference of about $7.1M per DALY is diagnostic only. All seven original worlds—including unknown, zero, adverse and public implementation cost—remain unchanged. Unknown is not zero, a completed combined valuation or an empirical 90%-health share.
The current campaign index identifies direct financial pathways, not only safety. The $3 Citi Bike campaign advocates an affordability change, not an implemented current gift-caused discount. Student OMNY expansion could reduce actual fares for currently excluded students or trips beyond the existing allowance; trips otherwise not made do not automatically represent displaced fare spending. These pathways require current adoption, actual eligibility and alternative payments. Existing public programs, appropriations and coalition work remain baseline.
Additional walking, cycling or transit can displace actual fuel, parking or car-ownership payments while adding fares, equipment and access costs. Toll, fine and registration changes may impose losses on other households. Commute time and job access are not gross wages: actual net resources after taxes, benefits withdrawn, additional work and opportunity costs require evidence. Injury events are not unique traveler or resource-sharing households. A numerical bridge needs donation-responsive project participation and mode changes, actual alternative spending, MSA residency and finite delay/duration. Full incurred negative costs remain independent of clinical response; positive health overlap applies only to gains. Public financing transfers and real implementation costs need distinct scope, without duplicating the existing public-cost diagnostic. No aggregate crash cost, VSL, retail medical value or ordinary survivor earnings is credited; broader transport resources remain unquantified, not zero.
The current cost per ten additional MSA-resident QALYs from an unrestricted gift is not established. Transportation Alternatives campaigns for safety improvements, but no source identifies how many additional corridor changes a gift causes, its share of a coalition's contribution, or the health effects of those changes.
The earlier $7.1M per DALY calculation remains below as a historical conditional diagnostic, not a measured central estimate or donor recommendation. It charged the full $5,186,682 annual recognized recipient expense to one street-injury pathway and assumed four corridor equivalents, 5.2 serious/fatal events per year from one selected street, 18.1% before/after injury association, 50% transfer, 25% incremental coalition effect, 30% TA share and 50% donation response. The implementation and attribution terms are not calibrated by those sources. Multiplying uncertain factors produces reproducible arithmetic, not a reliable unrestricted-gift estimate.
The historical exercise assigns finite health gains to avoided fatal and serious injuries, with explicit duration, utility and discounting choices; it does not value physical activity, air quality, accessibility, crash-family support, travel changes or harms. A separate illustrative public-cost case is not a construction quote. Zero implementation, donor substitution and adverse effects remain possible. A new central estimate would require a gift-responsive project pipeline, matched safety outcomes, defensible MSA residency and complete resource costs.
Model, assumptions and sensitivity
Whole recipient annual recognized gross expense; one partial-health pathway, not full portfolio. Public implementation and unrecognized volunteers excluded except sensitivity.
Official 22-county MSA residents only; g=.95 subjective injury-beneficiary residency, not population share or five-borough geography substitution.
Historical diagnostic only: A=sum(j=1..T)1.03^-j; D=u*(1-exp(-(ln(1.03)+m)*L))/(ln(1.03)+m); q=f*D+(1-f)*s; Qall=N*B*r*t*p*a*b*A*q-h; QNYC=g*Qall; price10=10*C/QNYC when positive. Current whole-recipient marginal health return is unidentified.
- N
- 4 conditional corridor equivalents (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- B
- 5.2 fatal/severe events per corridor-year (judgment). 5.2 derives from observed 26/5 on 31st Street; transfer to the modeled campaign portfolio is judgment. [dot]
- r
- 0.181 dimensionless or annual rate as formula defines (observed). Historical diagnostic: DOT's before/after all-road-user protected-bike-lane KSI association across 146 treatments; not randomized or attributable to this recipient. [dotstudy]
- t
- 0.5 dimensionless or annual rate as formula defines (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- p
- 0.25 dimensionless or annual rate as formula defines (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- a
- 0.3 dimensionless or annual rate as formula defines (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- b
- 0.5 dimensionless or annual rate as formula defines (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- T
- 5 benefit years (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- g
- 0.95 dimensionless or annual rate as formula defines (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- f
- 0.1 dimensionless or annual rate as formula defines (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- u
- 0.8 dimensionless or annual rate as formula defines (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- m
- 0.02 dimensionless or annual rate as formula defines (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- L
- 20 maximum survival years (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- s
- 1.50 discounted QALYs per severe nonfatal injury (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- h
- 0.00 all-population QALYs lost (judgment). Explicit conditional modeling prior, not calibrated empirical input. [campaigns] [harlem]
- C
- 5186682 USD/year (observed). FY2025 audited gross expense, return plus event costs. [audit25] [schedule2025]
Historical diagnostic — conditional street-injury pathway: Cost: $5.2M; New York City health QALYs: 0.73; all-population health QALYs: 0.76. {"N":4,"B":5.2,"r":0.181,"t":0.5,"p":0.25,"a":0.3,"b":0.5,"T":5,"g":0.95,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"L":20,"s":1.5,"h":0,"C":5186682}
Current unrestricted-gift effect — not established: Cost: $5.2M; New York City health QALYs: unknown; all-population health QALYs: unknown. Additional implementation, recipient attribution, funding response and whole-recipient health remain unidentified; unknown is not zero.
Historical diagnostic — low additional advocacy yield: Cost: $5.2M; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. {"N":1,"B":2,"r":0.1,"t":0.25,"p":0.1,"a":0.1,"b":0.1,"T":2,"g":0.9,"f":0.05,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"L":20,"s":0.5,"h":0,"C":5186682}
Historical diagnostic — broad favorable policy scenario: Cost: $5.2M; New York City health QALYs: 48.56; all-population health QALYs: 49.05. {"N":8,"B":5.2,"r":0.181,"t":1,"p":0.5,"a":0.5,"b":0.75,"T":10,"g":0.99,"f":0.15,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"L":20,"s":3,"h":0,"C":5186682}
Historical diagnostic — no incremental implementation: Cost: $5.2M; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. {"N":4,"B":5.2,"r":0.181,"t":0.5,"p":0,"a":0.3,"b":0.5,"T":5,"g":0.95,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"L":20,"s":1.5,"h":0,"C":5186682}
Historical diagnostic — displaced or harmful street changes: Cost: $5.2M; New York City health QALYs: -0.24; all-population health QALYs: -0.25. {"N":4,"B":5.2,"r":0.181,"t":0.5,"p":0,"a":0.3,"b":0.5,"T":5,"g":0.95,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"L":20,"s":1.5,"h":0.25,"C":5186682}
Historical diagnostic — illustrative induced public implementation cost: Cost: $5.5M; New York City health QALYs: 0.73; all-population health QALYs: 0.76. {"N":4,"B":5.2,"r":0.181,"t":0.5,"p":0.25,"a":0.3,"b":0.5,"T":5,"g":0.95,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"L":20,"s":1.5,"h":0,"C":5486682}
Counterfactual: Existing city plans, appropriations, other coalitions and replacement donations continue. Only additional or accelerated corridor-equivalent years receive credit; no historical completion receives a new gift's credit.
Attribution: p is incremental coalition effect, a TA's distinct share, b donation response. Each applied once. No independent credit to Families for Safe Streets or overlapping Open Plans work.
No current central unrestricted-gift estimate is established. Historical conditional partial-health scenarios contain uncalibrated implementation, attribution, funding and geographic choices; they are possibilities, not confidence bounds or a donor recommendation.
Sensitivity
- Historical diagnostics only: implementation yield, causal share and gift response multiply; a zero in any one eliminates modeled benefit.
- The favorable ten-year historical scenario yields about $110K per DALY, not an upper confidence bound or current donor price.
- Illustrative public construction costs raise the historical diagnostic; other transport benefits and harms remain unpriced.
Unresolved inputs
- Donation-responsive additional or accelerated corridor projects versus prior city commitments.
- Matched injury trends, corridor severity mix and MSA residency.
- Net public and volunteer resources and wider transport health effects.
- Current gift-responsive project/traveler and unique resource-sharing households; actual mode/vehicle ownership changes and alternatives; net fares/tolls/fuel/parking/equipment/private-care/time costs; tax/benefit effects, MSA residency and finite timing; public financing and disjoint implementation resource scope.
5. Funding and previous grants
March-ending audited expenses are $4,447,542 in FY2023, $5,135,283 in FY2024 and $5,186,682 in FY2025. Each reconciles to the original Form 990 expense plus separately netted fundraising costs of $67,853, $141,953 and $83,095 respectively. FY2024 expense includes a $206,481 employee-retention credit that reduced payroll-tax expense, so the three-year accounting mean is not an unadjusted recurring resource-cost baseline. No additional donated-service adjustment is reported in Schedule D; unrecognized volunteer opportunity costs remain outside this series. FY2025 audit, Note 15 FY2024/2023 audit
FY2025 support and revenue were $4,335,312 and ending net assets $3,270,676, of which $523,106 were restricted. The unrestricted decline was $426,460; the full $851,370 decline is not an unrestricted cash need. The board designated $1 million as a stability reserve. Two donors supplied about one-quarter of FY2025 support and revenue. These facts support asking about funding resilience but do not identify gift additionality. The directory's displayed FY2025 period conflicts with the original audit: the report uses the year ended March 31, 2025, not March 2026. Financial directory Donation route
Expense appendix: FY2025 recognized costs comprise $4,317,855 program services, $371,200 management/general and $497,627 fundraising. The three-year recognized accounting mean is $4,923,169; reversing the one-off FY2024 payroll-tax credit for a sensitivity would make the mean $4,991,996, not change audited expense. Neither series includes all public or volunteer opportunity cost. Schedule D establishes the tax-return reconciliations.
Annual expenses
Organization-level spending, including programs, administration and fundraising. The research list averages three comparable, consecutive full fiscal years when available.
- FY 2023: $4.4M; Transportation Alternatives Inc., EIN 51-0186015, 12-month period, March-ending accrual recognized gross recipient expense including separately netted fundraising costs.. Source
- FY 2024: $5.1M; Transportation Alternatives Inc., EIN 51-0186015, 12-month period, March-ending accrual recognized gross recipient expense including separately netted fundraising costs; reduced by a one-off $206,481 employee-retention payroll-tax credit, so not an unadjusted recurring-cost comparison.. Source
- FY 2025: $5.2M; Transportation Alternatives Inc., EIN 51-0186015, 12-month period, March-ending accrual recognized gross recipient expense including separately netted fundraising costs.. Source
6. Sources
- FY2025 audited statements. Transportation Alternatives. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- FY2024 audit with FY2023 comparative. Transportation Alternatives. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- FY2023 original Form 990. Transportation Alternatives / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- FY2023 original Schedule D reconciliation. Transportation Alternatives / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- FY2024 original Form 990. Transportation Alternatives / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- FY2024 original Schedule D reconciliation. Transportation Alternatives / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- FY2025 original Form 990. Transportation Alternatives / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- FY2025 original Schedule D reconciliation. Transportation Alternatives / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- Financial-document directory. Transportation Alternatives. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- Current citywide campaign portfolio. Transportation Alternatives. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- Central Harlem Bikeway campaign. Transportation Alternatives. Published: 2026-03-23; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- 31st Street safety redesign and local risk baseline. NYC DOT. Published: 2026-04-16; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- Safety Treatment Evaluation 2005–2018. NYC DOT. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Vision Zero equity and street safety report announcement. NYC DOT. Published: 2025-01-15; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- Official donation route. Transportation Alternatives. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-14.
- Current campaign index and fare-access mechanisms. Transportation Alternatives. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-07.
- Three-dollar Citi Bike affordability campaign. Transportation Alternatives. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-07.
- Student OMNY expansion campaign. Transportation Alternatives. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-07.