GiveBetter x New York City

Citizens Housing and Planning Council

Housing research, policy analysis and implementation advocacy

Research time: ~3 min on GPT-6 Astra Low + ~3 min on GPT-6.1 Sol
  • Research — reviewed programs, finances and impact evidence.
  • Source audit — checked claims, assumptions and calculations.
  • Modeling — estimated costs, QALYs and uncertainty.

Updated: 2026-10-08

Donate

Summary

What do they do? CHPC researches housing policy and advocates practical implementation changes in New York City. Its basement work seeks safe legalization, but CHPC does not directly build or provide housing. A conditional basement-health pathway estimates $13.0M per DALY using two years of the entire recipient's cost.

Why we’re interested in this organization:

  • A specific implementation agenda can potentially influence many homes.

  • Original returns permit recovery of event expenses omitted from headline costs.

  • The report accounts for existing legislation and city investment before assigning incremental advocacy credit.

Our main reservations:

  • Potential apartments and policy recommendations are not completed safety upgrades.

  • A donation's effect on implementation, occupancy and health remains unmeasured.

  • Construction costs, tenant displacement and exclusion of flood-prone homes can materially change net benefit.

What do you get for your dollar? $13.0M per DALY in New York City. DALY is our one-year comparison unit. QALY-based health gains and income-welfare equivalents retain their original assumptions; they are not measured clinical DALYs. Partial safe-basement clinical reference; household housing resources unknown.

Policy implementation change -> completed, occupied, safer homes -> finite respiratory and injury health.

1. What do they do?

Citizens Housing and Planning Council of New York Inc., EIN 13-1782468, researches housing, land use and neighborhood policy. It is distinct from the Massachusetts Citizens' Housing and Planning Association and from NYC housing agencies. The January 2026 agenda includes basement implementation, affordable-housing pipelines, costs and land-use administration; an ordinary gift supports this entire agenda. Current recommendations

2. Monitoring and information sharing

Track CHPC recommendations adopted beyond existing plans, the implementation change attributable to its work, actual safe occupied units and the timing difference versus baseline. Record displaced tenants, return rates, rents, remediated moisture, functioning egress/fire protection and injuries. CHPC's2016 Hidden Housing study estimated10,000–38,000 potential apartments under then-existing zoning; it is a technical opportunity estimate, not a current approved pipeline or measured output. Original research summary

3. Qualitative assessment

The scalable mechanism is making already-occupied unsafe homes safer sooner. Existing residents already have some shelter, so legal status and property appreciation receive no automatic QALYs. Current DOB rules describe a 10-year legalization route and exclude high-risk flood locations; it would be wrong to assign protection from every future Ida-like death to eligible conversions. Current program The2025 proposed rules specify egress, alarms and later sprinklers/flood sensors, plus tenant return procedures. Safety mechanism A small randomized housing-moisture remediation trial supports a respiratory-health mechanism for symptomatic asthmatic children receiving combined home and clinical intervention; the model's population prevalence and QALY conversion are separate judgments. Trial

Housing and tenant/owner net resources require targeted assessment; unknown is not zero.

4. What do you get for your dollar?

Signed housing resources are assessed unknown and potentially material. The retained conditional clinical reference remains about $13.0M per DALY, with 0.2853294414180609 MSA QALYs at $3,705,810 of two-year gross recipient cost. Every original world remains unchanged. This is not a combined portfolio valuation, zero-resource finding or measured 90% health share.

Hidden Housing identifies potential lower-rent basement apartments and homeowner rental income, while recommending financial incentives and tax protection. CHPC is a research organization, not a housing provider. Historical potential apartments and illustrative safe-unit equivalents do not establish new occupied households or actual rent savings. DOB implementation and existing public legislation/pilots remain counterfactual baseline; the November 2025 proposal discusses safety compliance, vacating and tenant return, not a new private-gift win.

A numerical bridge requires the current accelerated occupied-household pipeline, prior and post-legalization tenant/owner net payments, baseline resources and finite timing. Tenant rent and commuting/access savings must be assessed jointly with owner receipts net of taxes, financing, utilities and maintenance. Rent transfers are not automatic net gains; compliance, construction, relocation, temporary housing, administration and time costs can be negative and must not be discounted by clinical response. Positive overlap applies only to gains. Separate real public construction costs from financing transfers and household incidence without duplicate costs. No property asset value, fiscal budget or ordinary survivor earnings is counted. Broader policy resources remain unquantified, not absent.

Two years of full gross recipient cost total $3,705,810. The conditional model considers1,000 safely implemented units influenced by a possible administrative improvement, then applies 0.25 incremental implementation probability, 0.2 CHPC share and 0.5 financing response: 25 attributable unit-equivalents, or 0.00675 per $1,000. These are expected-value modeling units, not homes sold by CHPC. With 80% occupancy and 2 residents each, 40 attributable resident-equivalents receive at most five years of safer conditions beginning year2. Annual injury risk 0.0002, 50% risk reduction, 10% fatal severity and 0.3 nonfatal QALYs are judgments. Fatal gains have20-year survival cap, 0.8 utility, 2% mortality and 3% discount. Separately10% of residents receive 0.02 annual utility through respiratory improvement; no lifetime cure is assumed. A 20% offset allows displacement/other housing harms. Central benefit is 0.29 local QALYs. The1-year acceleration scenario is relevant if baseline implementation catches up quickly.

Model, assumptions and sensitivity

Two full annual gross recipient cost-equivalents including event expenses; other housing-policy effects provisionally netzero; induced construction cost separate.

All modeled safe occupancy is within NYC, therefore inside22-county OMB23-01 MSA; no benefit extrapolated to restofMSA or other states.

A=sum(t=start..start+T-1)exp(-m*(t-start+1))/(1+d)^t; D=sum(t=1..L)u*exp(-m*t)/(1+d)^t; U=N*p*a*b; Qall=U*o*n*A*(R*e*(f*D+(1-f)*j)+s*v)*(1-x)-h; Qlocal=g*Qall; cost=C*Y+publicCost; price10=cost/Qlocal if positive.

C
1852905 USD (observed). 1571694 Form990 expense+281211 PartVIII eventexpense=1852905. [990]
Y
2 years (judgment). Two years of wholeportfolio effort charged.
N
1000 formula-defined (judgment). 1000 conditional safeunits, below old10000–38000 potential; not a current forecast. [hidden]
p
0.25 formula-defined (judgment). 25% probability of incremental implementation beyond citybaseline.
a
0.2 formula-defined (judgment). 20% CHPC coalition causal credit.
b
0.5 formula-defined (judgment). Half gift changes capacity; no verified gap.
o
0.8 formula-defined (judgment). 80% actual occupied units.
n
2 formula-defined (judgment). Two residents perunit assumed.
g
1 formula-defined (judgment). NYC residents entirelyinsideMSA; no population-share allocation.
T
5 years (judgment). Five years of acceleration/additional safety then zero.
start
2 years (judgment). Benefit begins year2.
d
0.03 formula-defined (judgment). 3% discount.
m
0.02 formula-defined (judgment). 2% annual competing mortality.
R
0.0002 formula-defined (judgment). 0.0002 annual serious fire/flood injury risk, judgmentnotlocalrate.
e
0.5 formula-defined (judgment). Half injury risk prevented.
f
0.1 formula-defined (judgment). 10% injury fatality assumed.
u
0.8 formula-defined (judgment). .8 survivor utility.
L
20 years (judgment). 20-year remaining healthcap.
j
0.3 formula-defined (judgment). .3 total nonfatal injury QALYs, judgment.
s
0.1 formula-defined (judgment). 10% residents susceptible to respiratory improvement. [trial]
v
0.02 formula-defined (judgment). .02 annual utility benefit among susceptibles, not trialmapped. [trial]
x
0.2 formula-defined (judgment). 20% offset for displacement/other housing harms; unknown.
h
0 formula-defined (judgment). Additional other net harm zero centrally.
publicCost
0 USD (judgment). Recipient-only central; illustrative$1.3M retrofit resourcecost sensitivity.

Conditional faster safe-basement implementation: Cost: $3.7M; New York City health QALYs: 0.29; all-population health QALYs: 0.29. {"C":1852905,"Y":2,"N":1000,"p":0.25,"a":0.2,"b":0.5,"o":0.8,"n":2,"g":1,"T":5,"start":2,"d":0.03,"m":0.02,"R":0.0002,"e":0.5,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"L":20,"j":0.3,"s":0.1,"v":0.02,"x":0.2,"h":0,"publicCost":0}

Few units and small causal role: Cost: $3.7M; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. {"C":1852905,"Y":2,"N":200,"p":0.1,"a":0.1,"b":0.25,"o":0.8,"n":2,"g":1,"T":2,"start":2,"d":0.03,"m":0.02,"R":0.0002,"e":0.5,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"L":20,"j":0.3,"s":0.1,"v":0.005,"x":0.2,"h":0,"publicCost":0}

Scaled faster implementation: Cost: $3.7M; New York City health QALYs: 12.86; all-population health QALYs: 12.86. {"C":1852905,"Y":2,"N":5000,"p":0.5,"a":0.3,"b":0.75,"o":0.8,"n":2,"g":1,"T":10,"start":2,"d":0.03,"m":0.02,"R":0.0002,"e":0.5,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"L":20,"j":0.3,"s":0.1,"v":0.02,"x":0.1,"h":0,"publicCost":0}

No implementation change: Cost: $3.7M; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. {"C":1852905,"Y":2,"N":1000,"p":0,"a":0.2,"b":0.5,"o":0.8,"n":2,"g":1,"T":5,"start":2,"d":0.03,"m":0.02,"R":0.0002,"e":0.5,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"L":20,"j":0.3,"s":0.1,"v":0.02,"x":0.2,"h":0,"publicCost":0}

No benefit and displacement harm: Cost: $3.7M; New York City health QALYs: -1.00; all-population health QALYs: -1.00. {"C":1852905,"Y":2,"N":1000,"p":0,"a":0.2,"b":0.5,"o":0.8,"n":2,"g":1,"T":5,"start":2,"d":0.03,"m":0.02,"R":0.0002,"e":0.5,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"L":20,"j":0.3,"s":0.1,"v":0.02,"x":0.2,"h":1,"publicCost":0}

Illustrative attributed retrofit resources: Cost: $5.0M; New York City health QALYs: 0.29; all-population health QALYs: 0.29. {"C":1852905,"Y":2,"N":1000,"p":0.25,"a":0.2,"b":0.5,"o":0.8,"n":2,"g":1,"T":5,"start":2,"d":0.03,"m":0.02,"R":0.0002,"e":0.5,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"L":20,"j":0.3,"s":0.1,"v":0.02,"x":0.2,"h":0,"publicCost":1250000}

No respiratory improvement: Cost: $3.7M; New York City health QALYs: 0.02; all-population health QALYs: 0.02. {"C":1852905,"Y":2,"N":1000,"p":0.25,"a":0.2,"b":0.5,"o":0.8,"n":2,"g":1,"T":5,"start":2,"d":0.03,"m":0.02,"R":0.0002,"e":0.5,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"L":20,"j":0.3,"s":0.1,"v":0,"x":0.2,"h":0,"publicCost":0}

One-year acceleration only: Cost: $3.7M; New York City health QALYs: 0.06; all-population health QALYs: 0.06. {"C":1852905,"Y":2,"N":1000,"p":0.25,"a":0.2,"b":0.5,"o":0.8,"n":2,"g":1,"T":1,"start":2,"d":0.03,"m":0.02,"R":0.0002,"e":0.5,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"L":20,"j":0.3,"s":0.1,"v":0.02,"x":0.2,"h":0,"publicCost":0}

Combined resources unknown; clinical reference retained: Cost: $3.7M; New York City health QALYs: 0.29; all-population health QALYs: 0.29. Original clinical and two-year gross recipient cost retained; signed household resources unknown, not zero.

Counterfactual: Existing state/local legislation, DOB/HPD staffing, funded city pilot, homeowners and other advocates proceed. Only additional or accelerated safety outcomes get credit; modeled five-year catch-up gap is uncertain.

Attribution: N conditional units relevant to this mixed advocacy portfolio; p incremental implementation chance, a CHPC causal share, b net financing response. No whole-city housing stock or coalition-wide outcome is credited. Public funding is baseline, not private gift leverage automatically.

Very weak conditional partial-health model; potential technical capacity, causal implementation, incremental timing and health all uncertain. Scenarios are hypotheses, not confidence intervals. N=1000 is an illustrative implementation scale with no verified current pipeline. No actual unit production or adoption attributable to CHPC is established.

Sensitivity

  • If city implementation happens anyway or CHPC has no influence, price is undefined because health benefit is zero.
  • Five-year advantage can be too long where public baseline accelerates; one-year catch-up sensitivity makes this explicit.
  • Mortality and respiratory effects are separately serialized; injury-only removes the larger morbidity hypothesis. Displacement can exceed modeled gains.

Unresolved inputs

  • Current eligible and funded unitpipeline, implementation bottleneck and attribution evidence.
  • Resident risk, asthma/moistureprevalence, actual safetyupgrades and duration advantage.
  • Marginal unrestricted allocation, costed CHPCcapacity, construction/publicresources and displacement.
  • Current accelerated occupied household pipeline, prior and post-legalization tenant/owner net payments, rent-transfer distribution, financing and subsidy incidence, full relocation/compliance burdens, baseline resources and finite delay/duration.

5. Funding and previous grants

FY2024 Form 990 expense is $1,571,694, but Part VIII also nets $281,211 event costs from revenue; full gross recipient cost is $1,852,905. FY2023 analogously adds $259,755 to $1,617,518 for $1,877,273. Schedule D repeats the net presentation; it does not eliminate the real event resources. FY2024 net assets total $2,501,602, of which $2,364,762 are unrestricted. 2024 original return 2023 original return No costed unfunded implementation position was located; reserves and broad advocacy scope make 0.5 gift responsiveness uncertain. The mayor reported more than $1 million invested in the city legalization effort by August 2026; this continues in the counterfactual and is not assigned to CHPC. Current public baseline Recipient expense excludes owners' retrofit and public administration costs; an illustrative25 attributed units*$50,000=$1.25 million addition shows one resource sensitivity, not measured construction cost.

Annual expenses

Organization-level spending, including programs, administration and fundraising. The research list averages three comparable, consecutive full fiscal years when available.

  • FY 2023: $1.9M; Citizens Housing and Planning Council of New York Inc., 12-month period, Calendar-year recognizedgross expense: Form990total+separatelynetted eventcost. Source
  • FY 2024: $1.9M; Citizens Housing and Planning Council of New York Inc., 12-month period, Calendar-year recognizedgross expense: Form990total+separatelynetted eventcost. Source

6. Sources

  1. FY2024 original Form990. CHPC/IRS, hosted by ProPublica. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
  2. FY2023 original Form990. CHPC/IRS, hosted by ProPublica. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
  3. FY2024 ScheduleD reconciliation. CHPC/IRS, hosted by ProPublica. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
  4. January2026 housing recommendations. CHPC. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
  5. Hidden Housing research. CHPC. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-08.
  6. Current ADU and legalization program. NYC Buildings. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-08.
  7. Legalization safety and tenant requirements. NYC Buildings. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-08.
  8. August2026 implementation investment. NYC Mayor's Office. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
  9. Home moisture remediation randomized trial. Kercsmar et al., Environmental Health Perspectives. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
  10. Donation route. CHPC. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.