{"edition":"new-york-city","organization":"Citizens Housing and Planning Council","organizationId":"org:citizens-housing-and-planning-council","boundaryVersion":"OMB-23-01-2023-07-21","updated":"2026-10-08","display":{"metric":{"id":"daly-equivalent","years":1,"label":"DALY","priceLabel":"$ / DALY"},"priceUSD":12987829.02171773,"canonicalPriceUSDPerTenEquivalentYears":129878290.2171773,"conversion":"display only; QALYs and income equivalents are not measured clinical DALYs"},"listDisplay":{"metric":{"id":"daly-equivalent","years":1,"label":"DALY","priceLabel":"$ / DALY"},"priceUSD":12987829.02171773,"canonicalPriceUSDPerTenEquivalentYears":129878290.2171773,"conversion":"display only; QALYs and income equivalents are not measured clinical DALYs"},"model":{"version":"nyc-chpc-targeted-resources-assessed-unknown-v2","costScope":"Two full annual gross recipient cost-equivalents including event expenses; other housing-policy effects provisionally netzero; induced construction cost separate.","geographicAttribution":"All modeled safe occupancy is within NYC, therefore inside22-county OMB23-01 MSA; no benefit extrapolated to restofMSA or other states.","formula":"A=sum(t=start..start+T-1)exp(-m*(t-start+1))/(1+d)^t; D=sum(t=1..L)u*exp(-m*t)/(1+d)^t; U=N*p*a*b; Qall=U*o*n*A*(R*e*(f*D+(1-f)*j)+s*v)*(1-x)-h; Qlocal=g*Qall; cost=C*Y+publicCost; price10=10*cost/Qlocal if positive.","counterfactual":"Existing state/local legislation, DOB/HPD staffing, funded city pilot, homeowners and other advocates proceed. Only additional or accelerated safety outcomes get credit; modeled five-year catch-up gap is uncertain.","attribution":"N conditional units relevant to this mixed advocacy portfolio; p incremental implementation chance, a CHPC causal share, b net financing response. No whole-city housing stock or coalition-wide outcome is credited. Public funding is baseline, not private gift leverage automatically.","uncertainty":"Very weak conditional partial-health model; potential technical capacity, causal implementation, incremental timing and health all uncertain. Scenarios are hypotheses, not confidence intervals. N=1000 is an illustrative implementation scale with no verified current pipeline. No actual unit production or adoption attributable to CHPC is established.","nativeOutcomes":"Policy implementation change -> completed, occupied, safer homes -> finite respiratory and injury health.","nativeCosts":"Central25 attributable safe unit-equivalents over two-year recipient cost, $148,232 per equivalent. Actual direct service output is policy analysis, not units provided.","centralParameters":{"C":1852905,"Y":2,"N":1000,"p":0.25,"a":0.2,"b":0.5,"o":0.8,"n":2,"g":1,"T":5,"start":2,"d":0.03,"m":0.02,"R":0.0002,"e":0.5,"f":0.1,"u":0.8,"L":20,"j":0.3,"s":0.1,"v":0.02,"x":0.2,"h":0,"publicCost":0},"inputs":[{"name":"C","value":1852905,"unit":"USD","basis":"observed","rationale":"1571694 Form990 expense+281211 PartVIII eventexpense=1852905.","sourceIds":["990"]},{"name":"Y","value":2,"unit":"years","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Two years of wholeportfolio effort charged.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"N","value":1000,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"1000 conditional safeunits, below old10000–38000 potential; not a current forecast.","sourceIds":["hidden"]},{"name":"p","value":0.25,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"25% probability of incremental implementation beyond citybaseline.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"a","value":0.2,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"20% CHPC coalition causal credit.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"b","value":0.5,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Half gift changes capacity; no verified gap.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"o","value":0.8,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"80% actual occupied units.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"n","value":2,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Two residents perunit assumed.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"g","value":1,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"NYC residents entirelyinsideMSA; no population-share allocation.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"T","value":5,"unit":"years","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Five years of acceleration/additional safety then zero.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"start","value":2,"unit":"years","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Benefit begins year2.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"d","value":0.03,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"3% discount.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"m","value":0.02,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"2% annual competing mortality.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"R","value":0.0002,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"0.0002 annual serious fire/flood injury risk, judgmentnotlocalrate.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"e","value":0.5,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Half injury risk prevented.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"f","value":0.1,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"10% injury fatality assumed.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"u","value":0.8,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":".8 survivor utility.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"L","value":20,"unit":"years","basis":"judgment","rationale":"20-year remaining healthcap.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"j","value":0.3,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":".3 total nonfatal injury QALYs, judgment.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"s","value":0.1,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"10% residents susceptible to respiratory improvement.","sourceIds":["trial"]},{"name":"v","value":0.02,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":".02 annual utility benefit among susceptibles, not trialmapped.","sourceIds":["trial"]},{"name":"x","value":0.2,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"20% offset for displacement/other housing harms; unknown.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"h","value":0,"unit":"formula-defined","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Additional other net harm zero centrally.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"publicCost","value":0,"unit":"USD","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Recipient-only central; illustrative$1.25m retrofit resourcecost sensitivity.","sourceIds":[]}],"scenarios":[{"id":"central","label":"Conditional faster safe-basement implementation","costUSD":3705810,"allPopulationQalys":0.2853294414180609,"editionQalys":0.2853294414180609,"pricePer10Qalys":129878290.2171773,"parameterOverrides":{},"assumptions":"{\"C\":1852905,\"Y\":2,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.25,\"a\":0.2,\"b\":0.5,\"o\":0.8,\"n\":2,\"g\":1,\"T\":5,\"start\":2,\"d\":0.03,\"m\":0.02,\"R\":0.0002,\"e\":0.5,\"f\":0.1,\"u\":0.8,\"L\":20,\"j\":0.3,\"s\":0.1,\"v\":0.02,\"x\":0.2,\"h\":0,\"publicCost\":0}"},{"id":"low","label":"Few units and small causal role","costUSD":3705810,"allPopulationQalys":0.0007224514934626281,"editionQalys":0.0007224514934626281,"pricePer10Qalys":51294931680.99733,"parameterOverrides":{"N":200,"p":0.1,"a":0.1,"b":0.25,"T":2,"v":0.005},"assumptions":"{\"C\":1852905,\"Y\":2,\"N\":200,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"o\":0.8,\"n\":2,\"g\":1,\"T\":2,\"start\":2,\"d\":0.03,\"m\":0.02,\"R\":0.0002,\"e\":0.5,\"f\":0.1,\"u\":0.8,\"L\":20,\"j\":0.3,\"s\":0.1,\"v\":0.005,\"x\":0.2,\"h\":0,\"publicCost\":0}"},{"id":"high","label":"Scaled faster implementation","costUSD":3705810,"allPopulationQalys":12.859635387172126,"editionQalys":12.859635387172126,"pricePer10Qalys":2881738.0030048573,"parameterOverrides":{"N":5000,"p":0.5,"a":0.3,"b":0.75,"T":10,"x":0.1},"assumptions":"{\"C\":1852905,\"Y\":2,\"N\":5000,\"p\":0.5,\"a\":0.3,\"b\":0.75,\"o\":0.8,\"n\":2,\"g\":1,\"T\":10,\"start\":2,\"d\":0.03,\"m\":0.02,\"R\":0.0002,\"e\":0.5,\"f\":0.1,\"u\":0.8,\"L\":20,\"j\":0.3,\"s\":0.1,\"v\":0.02,\"x\":0.1,\"h\":0,\"publicCost\":0}"},{"id":"zero","label":"No implementation change","costUSD":3705810,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"pricePer10Qalys":null,"parameterOverrides":{"p":0},"assumptions":"{\"C\":1852905,\"Y\":2,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0,\"a\":0.2,\"b\":0.5,\"o\":0.8,\"n\":2,\"g\":1,\"T\":5,\"start\":2,\"d\":0.03,\"m\":0.02,\"R\":0.0002,\"e\":0.5,\"f\":0.1,\"u\":0.8,\"L\":20,\"j\":0.3,\"s\":0.1,\"v\":0.02,\"x\":0.2,\"h\":0,\"publicCost\":0}"},{"id":"adverse","label":"No benefit and displacement harm","costUSD":3705810,"allPopulationQalys":-1,"editionQalys":-1,"pricePer10Qalys":null,"parameterOverrides":{"p":0,"h":1},"assumptions":"{\"C\":1852905,\"Y\":2,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0,\"a\":0.2,\"b\":0.5,\"o\":0.8,\"n\":2,\"g\":1,\"T\":5,\"start\":2,\"d\":0.03,\"m\":0.02,\"R\":0.0002,\"e\":0.5,\"f\":0.1,\"u\":0.8,\"L\":20,\"j\":0.3,\"s\":0.1,\"v\":0.02,\"x\":0.2,\"h\":1,\"publicCost\":0}"},{"id":"public-cost","label":"Illustrative attributed retrofit resources","costUSD":4955810,"allPopulationQalys":0.2853294414180609,"editionQalys":0.2853294414180609,"pricePer10Qalys":173687298.98218998,"parameterOverrides":{"publicCost":1250000},"assumptions":"{\"C\":1852905,\"Y\":2,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.25,\"a\":0.2,\"b\":0.5,\"o\":0.8,\"n\":2,\"g\":1,\"T\":5,\"start\":2,\"d\":0.03,\"m\":0.02,\"R\":0.0002,\"e\":0.5,\"f\":0.1,\"u\":0.8,\"L\":20,\"j\":0.3,\"s\":0.1,\"v\":0.02,\"x\":0.2,\"h\":0,\"publicCost\":1250000}"},{"id":"injury-only","label":"No respiratory improvement","costUSD":3705810,"allPopulationQalys":0.016912759602174556,"editionQalys":0.016912759602174556,"pricePer10Qalys":2191132663.840102,"parameterOverrides":{"v":0},"assumptions":"{\"C\":1852905,\"Y\":2,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.25,\"a\":0.2,\"b\":0.5,\"o\":0.8,\"n\":2,\"g\":1,\"T\":5,\"start\":2,\"d\":0.03,\"m\":0.02,\"R\":0.0002,\"e\":0.5,\"f\":0.1,\"u\":0.8,\"L\":20,\"j\":0.3,\"s\":0.1,\"v\":0,\"x\":0.2,\"h\":0,\"publicCost\":0}"},{"id":"short-acceleration","label":"One-year acceleration only","costUSD":3705810,"allPopulationQalys":0.06285744410247156,"editionQalys":0.06285744410247156,"pricePer10Qalys":589557856.3389738,"parameterOverrides":{"T":1},"assumptions":"{\"C\":1852905,\"Y\":2,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.25,\"a\":0.2,\"b\":0.5,\"o\":0.8,\"n\":2,\"g\":1,\"T\":1,\"start\":2,\"d\":0.03,\"m\":0.02,\"R\":0.0002,\"e\":0.5,\"f\":0.1,\"u\":0.8,\"L\":20,\"j\":0.3,\"s\":0.1,\"v\":0.02,\"x\":0.2,\"h\":0,\"publicCost\":0}"},{"id":"combined-income-unknown","label":"Combined resources unknown; clinical reference retained","costUSD":3705810,"allPopulationQalys":0.2853294414180609,"editionQalys":0.2853294414180609,"incomeUnknown":true,"assumptions":"Original clinical and two-year gross recipient cost retained; signed household resources unknown, not zero."}],"sensitivity":["If city implementation happens anyway or CHPC has no influence, price is undefined because health benefit is zero.","Five-year advantage can be too long where public baseline accelerates; one-year catch-up sensitivity makes this explicit.","Mortality and respiratory effects are separately serialized; injury-only removes the larger morbidity hypothesis. Displacement can exceed modeled gains."],"missingInputs":["Current eligible and funded unitpipeline, implementation bottleneck and attribution evidence.","Resident risk, asthma/moistureprevalence, actual safetyupgrades and duration advantage.","Marginal unrestricted allocation, costed CHPCcapacity, construction/publicresources and displacement.","Current accelerated occupied household pipeline, prior and post-legalization tenant/owner net payments, rent-transfer distribution, financing and subsidy incidence, full relocation/compliance burdens, baseline resources and finite delay/duration."],"incomeAssessment":{"status":"assessed-unknown","materiality":"targeted","acceptance":"independently-reviewed","evidence":"docs/geography-discovery/nyc-chpc-alpha-income-20261008/root-acceptance.md","sourceIds":["hidden","dob","safety"],"rationale":"Original Hidden Housing identifies lower-rent apartments and homeowner rental income; legalization also entails compliance and relocation costs. These are household resource mechanisms, but potential apartments and illustrative safe-unit equivalents do not identify new rent savings, owner net income, actual payment amounts or a current marginal pipeline.","directions":["Tenant rent and commuting/access savings versus existing illegal occupancy or alternative housing; owner rent receipts net of displaced receipts, taxes, financing, utilities and maintenance.","Full compliance, construction, moving, temporary rent, administration and time burdens independent of respiratory or injury response; rent transfers require renter/owner joint incidence.","Existing legislation, public pilot and funded implementation remain baseline; property asset values and fiscal budgets are not household consumption."],"missing":"Current accelerated occupied household pipeline, prior and post-legalization tenant/owner net payments, rent-transfer distribution, financing and subsidy incidence, full relocation/compliance burdens, baseline resources and finite delay/duration."}},"sources":[{"id":"990","title":"FY2024 original Form990","publisher":"CHPC/IRS, hosted by ProPublica","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202503219349311945/IRS990","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-29"},{"id":"99023","title":"FY2023 original Form990","publisher":"CHPC/IRS, hosted by ProPublica","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202443209349311019/IRS990","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-29"},{"id":"schedule","title":"FY2024 ScheduleD reconciliation","publisher":"CHPC/IRS, hosted by ProPublica","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202503219349311945/IRS990ScheduleD","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-29"},{"id":"agenda","title":"January2026 housing recommendations","publisher":"CHPC","url":"https://chpcny.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/01/Housing-Recommendations-for-a-New-Administration-1.pdf","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-29"},{"id":"hidden","title":"Hidden Housing research","publisher":"CHPC","url":"https://chpcny.org/publication/hidden-housing/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-08"},{"id":"dob","title":"Current ADU and legalization program","publisher":"NYC Buildings","url":"https://www.nyc.gov/site/buildings/codes/adu.page","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-08"},{"id":"safety","title":"Legalization safety and tenant requirements","publisher":"NYC Buildings","url":"https://www.nyc.gov/site/buildings/dob/pr-legalizing-basement.page","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-08"},{"id":"baseline","title":"August2026 implementation investment","publisher":"NYC Mayor's Office","url":"https://www.nyc.gov/bn/mayors-office/news/2026/08/transcript--mayor-mamdani-holds-ethnic-and-community-media-round","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-29"},{"id":"trial","title":"Home moisture remediation randomized trial","publisher":"Kercsmar et al., Environmental Health Perspectives","url":"https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1626393/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-29"},{"id":"donate","title":"Donation route","publisher":"CHPC","url":"https://chpcny.org/donate/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-29"}]}