GiveBetter x New York City

Samaritans of New York

Whole recipient; conditional crisis hotline health and signed net household resources

Research time: ~3 min on GPT-6 Astra Low + ~6 min on GPT-6.1 Sol
  • Research — reviewed programs, finances and impact evidence.
  • Source audit — checked claims, assumptions and calculations.

Updated: 2026-10-05

Donate

Summary

What do they do? Samaritans of New York offers free, anonymous, confidential, round-the-clock emotional support and suicide prevention. The recipient also offers bereavement support and public education, whose separate effects are not monetized here. We examine incremental crisis episodes supported by an ordinary gift against existing free NYC988 and other support, with signed household-resource effects.

Why we’re interested in this organization:

  • Current operator pages identify a specific active hotline and its consent and privacy policies.

  • Original fiscal returns reconcile annual recipient costs, including separately netted event expense in FY2022.

  • The model distinguishes calls from episodes and values common-alive distress and net cash effects without adding survivor earnings.

Our main reservations:

  • Unique callers, causal death prevention, persistent utility change and extra gift-funded capacity are not observed.

  • Free NYC988 is a substantive alternative; hotline studies do not measure this recipient’s next-dollar effect.

  • The conditional central is about $3.1M per DALY, with slightly negative net resources; null, adverse and funding-replacement cases are explicit.

What do you get for your dollar? $3.1M per DALY in New York City. DALY is our one-year comparison unit. QALY-based health gains and income-welfare equivalents retain their original assumptions; they are not measured clinical DALYs. Conditional whole-recipient crisis engagement with signed household resources; initial health-only model retained as a diagnostic. Not a verified additional-call or treatment offer..

{"calls":72.34771809996896,"episodes":14.469543619993793,"clinicalEquivalent":4.340863085998138,"mortality":0.00220297876750659,"morbidity":0.002077937097685984,"harm":0.00014467579114321434,"MSAhealth":0.003308992059239487,"signedResources":-0.00005663144533048094,"combined":0.0032523606139090062}

1. What do they do?

The recipient is Samaritans of New York Inc., EIN 13-3164464. Its current crisis page describes free 24/7 anonymous confidential listening, no caller tracing unless location is shared and no police/EMS action without caller consent. Ordinary telephone-provider charges may still apply. Its overview also offers bereavement and education. An unrestricted gift does not create a verified restricted hotline slot. The model conservatively charges the whole recipient’s cost while counting only conditional crisis effects; other portfolio effects remain unknown rather than zero.

2. Monitoring and information sharing

The latest original return reports FY 2024-labeled 37,734 contacts, including 29,129 crisis calls. They are not unique callers or resolved independent episodes. The overview’s 50,000 contacts/30,000 volunteerhours and older 2023 education/bereavement totals have different reporting scope and dates and are not a matched current denominator. Anonymous service limits residence and unique-person measurement. Needed data include privacy-preserving repeat-episode counts, wait/abandon rates, unmet demand, follow-up retention, actual clinical outcomes, local residence, covered staffing and a dated next-dollar capacity plan. No source supplies these measurements.

3. Qualitative assessment

Gould 2007 followed 1,085 suicidal callers at eight US centers; 380 (35%) completed follow-up. Distress and suicidality fell, but there was no untreated control, substantial follow-up attrition and no generic utility or causal mortality estimate. The original randomized ASIST training study compares trained versus existing counselors, not a hotline versus no help; its primary indexed abstract supports immediate distress outcomes, not deaths averted. Full text was inaccessible in this pass, so no numerical effect is imported. The 2026 national 988 study compares observed 15–34-year-old mortality with a forecast after the national launch, not an isolated Samaritans donation. Its 11% national association cannot identify this program’s effect. Current NYC 988 offers free 24/7 calls/text/chat, languages, referrals and follow-up. Noncoercive anonymous listening may reach people avoiding other routes; it may also delay escalation for some crises. Consent policy is not proof that net harms are absent. Independent delay/safety harm is modeled, with adverse/null cases.

The primary Gould full text also excludes 654 callers considered too acutely suicidal to administer the assessment, adding selection bias to follow-up attrition. The assumed episode multiplier is an approximate repeat-contact adjustment, not a verified distinct-person registry; repeated crises within one person remain a source of uncertainty. Mortality probabilities are deliberately small, but this does not establish real unique lives saved.

4. What do you get for your dollar?

Our conditional combined estimate is $3.1M per DALY: one modeled equivalent year in the NYC metro area. The initial health-only estimate was $1.4M. The change reflects revised crisis-episode, clinical and household-resource assumptions, not an observed deterioration in the hotline.

What additional funding could provide. The latest annual expense is $1.29 million. Historical crisis-call volume, a judged current-scale transfer and a 40% funding response imply about 72 additional call equivalents per $10,000 mathematical normalization, or roughly $138 per additional call equivalent. Assuming five contacts per independent crisis gives about 14.5 crisis episodes, or $691 per episode. These are conditional average-support calculations, not verified additional staffing prices or unique callers. The full recipient's administration, fundraising, education and support costs are charged once; donated volunteer hours are not automatically monetized or added twice.

Health. Existing free NYC988 and other help remain in the counterfactual. The model assumes a modest acute mortality-risk difference among a judged high-risk subgroup, one-day response delay and a finite twenty-year survival tail. Short-lived distress improvement applies only to people alive in both worlds. A separate safety/delay burden remains in clinical-null cases. Hotline studies support the plausibility of immediate relief, not these numerical mortality or generic-utility assumptions. Repeat contacts and unique crisis episodes are uncertain.

Net household resources. Small one-off phone charges and uncovered care or transport costs are subtracted after free calling, insurance and other support. A small response group avoids actual lost disposable pay, net of taxes, benefits, paid leave and work costs. Caller time, gross wages, ordinary earnings of newly surviving participants and retail value of free services receive no cash credit. Nested care/no-care groups use a shared resource ledger rather than duplicate receipts.

The Coefficient Giving-inspired logarithmic comparison uses a judged $25,000 annual household-resource baseline. Common-alive survival, dated receipt, local attribution and discounting apply once. Half of positive income-equivalent welfare is retained to reduce overlap with distress relief; negative resource costs are charged fully. These are unmeasured resource priors, not caller financial outcomes.

At the $10,000 mathematical normalization—not a gift recommendation—the central case yields about 0.00 health years and 0.00 income-equivalent years, or 0.00 combined years. Scaling funding and activity together does not change the price. The twenty scenarios include weaker and stronger clinical responses, repeated contacts, delay, low acute risk, shorter survival, signed pay losses, overlap, zero expansion, full clinical substitution and adverse outcomes. An external-resource companion adds $100 per episode for selected unrecognized volunteer or public resources, not a complete societal-cost inventory. Other portfolio benefits, unique-person outcomes and actual gift-sensitive capacity remain unmeasured.

Model, assumptions and sensitivity

Donor marginal capacity scenario from full annual average expense; unknown external volunteer/public resources not known zero.

g=.8 anonymous-caller MSA residence judgment; applied once to health and each income path.

k=ln(1+r); F(q,t)=(1-exp(-q*t))/q; E=G*b*N*f*episode/C; B=E*a; survival gain=B*s*R*e*exp(-(m+k)*L)*u*F(m+k,T); common-alive morbidity=B*(1-sR)*p*v*exp(-(m+k)*L)*F(m+k,days/365); harm=E*h*exp(-(m+k)*L); H=mortality+morbidity-harm. Income=.5*people*ln(1+gain/sequentialBaseline)*commonAlive(receipt)*g*independence/(1+r)^receipt; price10=10*(G+E*external)/(g*H+income), null if denominator<=0.

G
10000 USD (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
C
1288400 USD (observed). Fresh original audit reconciliation [990] [schedule]
N
29129 calls (observed). Historical FY2024-labeled crisis calls, not current unique cohort [990]
f
0.8 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
b
0.4 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
episode
0.2 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
a
0.3 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
s
0.25 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
R
0.002 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
e
0.1 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
u
0.8 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
m
0.02 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
T
20 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
L
0.0027397260273972603 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
r
0.03 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
g
0.8 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
p
0.25 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
v
0.05 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
days
14 days (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
h
0.00001 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
households
0.7 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
Y
25000 USD (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
phone
0.25 USD (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
careShare
0.02 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
careCost
20 USD (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
workShare
0.02 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
netPay
30 USD (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
positiveIndependent
0.5 model scalar (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]
external
0 USD (judgment). Unmeasured conditional planning prior; inspect formula and signed sensitivities, not observed causal input [crisis] [988] [gould] [income-cg]

Conditional hotline and signed household resources: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.00220297876750659; morbidity=0.002077937097685984; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.00005663144533048094; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Weak additional response and greater cash burden: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.15,"episode":0.2,"a":0.1,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.02,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":5,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.1,"v":0.02,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":1,"careShare":0.05,"careCost":40,"workShare":0,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=27.130394287488357; independent episodes=5.4260788574976715; mortality=0.000019221615034954973; morbidity=0.00004155874195371967; harm=0.00005425342167870535; MSA income equivalent=-0.0001819575004135276; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Stronger response and avoided net pay: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.02; all-population health QALYs: 0.03. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.6,"episode":0.2,"a":0.6,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.2,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":25,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.4,"v":0.08,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0,"careShare":0.01,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.05,"netPay":60,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=108.52157714995343; independent episodes=21.704315429990686; mortality=0.0149300108558115; morbidity=0.01595855691022836; harm=0.0002170136867148214; MSA income equivalent=0.00031476192947483536; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

No gift-induced expansion: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=0; independent episodes=0; mortality=0; morbidity=0; harm=0; MSA income equivalent=0; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

No benefit; health and cash burdens remain: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: -0.02; all-population health QALYs: -0.03. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.002,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":2,"careShare":0.1,"careCost":50,"workShare":0,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0; morbidity=0; harm=0.02893515822864286; MSA income equivalent=-0.0011324251508047969; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

No clinical effect; signed resource effects remain: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0; morbidity=0; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.00005663144533048094; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Existing services remove clinical advantage: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0; morbidity=0; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.00005663144533048094; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

No additional deaths averted: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0; morbidity=0.002077937097685984; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.00005663144533048094; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

No additional distress utility improvement: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.00220297876750659; morbidity=0; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.00005663144533048094; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

No avoided lost pay: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.00220297876750659; morbidity=0.002077937097685984; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.000105098122023986; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Positive resource welfare entirely overlaps health: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.00220297876750659; morbidity=0.002077937097685984; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.000105098122023986; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Positive cash effect entirely independent: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":1,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.00220297876750659; morbidity=0.002077937097685984; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.00000816476863697587; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Ten contacts per independent crisis: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.1,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=7.2347718099968965; mortality=0.001101489383753295; morbidity=0.001038968548842992; harm=0.00007233789557160717; MSA income equivalent=-0.00002831572266524047; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Historical reach transfers at half scale: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.5,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=45.21732381248059; independent episodes=9.04346476249612; mortality=0.0013768617296916188; morbidity=0.0012987106860537399; harm=0.00009042236946450894; MSA income equivalent=-0.00003539465333155057; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Five-year finite survival tail: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":5,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.000768864601398199; morbidity=0.002077937097685984; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.00005663144533048094; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Thirty-day response delay: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0821917808219178,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.0021943214868052853; morbidity=0.0020697712065754297; harm=0.00014410724325111284; MSA income equivalent=-0.00005640889469768411; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Lower acute episode fatal risk: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.0005,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.0005507446918766475; morbidity=0.0020787167139057258; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.000056652692746187724; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Referral/engagement reduces net disposable pay: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":-30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.00220297876750659; morbidity=0.002077937097685984; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.0002021478683278851; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Selected unrecognized volunteer/public resources: Cost: $11K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":25000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":100}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.00220297876750659; morbidity=0.002077937097685984; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.00005663144533048094; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Lower household resource reference: Cost: $10K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"G":10000,"C":1288400,"N":29129,"f":0.8,"b":0.4,"episode":0.2,"a":0.3,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"u":0.8,"m":0.02,"T":20,"L":0.0027397260273972603,"r":0.03,"g":0.8,"p":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.00001,"households":0.7,"Y":10000,"phone":0.25,"careShare":0.02,"careCost":20,"workShare":0.02,"netPay":30,"positiveIndependent":0.5,"external":0}; calls=72.34771809996896; independent episodes=14.469543619993793; mortality=0.00220297876750659; morbidity=0.002077937097685984; harm=0.00014467579114321434; MSA income equivalent=-0.00014178306405381326; unweighted judgment sensitivity, not confidence interval.

Historical alpha diagnostic: Conditional crisis listening health: Cost: $1.3M; New York City health QALYs: 0.93; all-population health QALYs: 1.16. Preserved prior health-only diagnostic, not current combined estimate. {"C":1288400,"N":29129,"z":0.2,"l":1,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"r":0.4,"a":0.8,"b":0.6,"g":0.8,"u":0.8,"L":25,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"w":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0,"volunteerCost":0}

Historical alpha diagnostic: High repeat use and limited incremental effects: Cost: $1.3M; New York City health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.02. Preserved prior health-only diagnostic, not current combined estimate. {"C":1288400,"N":29129,"z":0.1,"l":1,"s":0.25,"R":0.0005,"e":0.05,"r":0.2,"a":0.8,"b":0.3,"g":0.5,"u":0.8,"L":25,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"w":0.1,"v":0.05,"days":3,"h":0,"volunteerCost":0}

Historical alpha diagnostic: More unique episodes and effective support: Cost: $1.3M; New York City health QALYs: 12.01; all-population health QALYs: 12.65. Preserved prior health-only diagnostic, not current combined estimate. {"C":1288400,"N":29129,"z":0.4,"l":1,"s":0.25,"R":0.003,"e":0.2,"r":0.6,"a":0.8,"b":0.8,"g":0.95,"u":0.8,"L":25,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"w":0.4,"v":0.05,"days":21,"h":0,"volunteerCost":0}

Historical alpha diagnostic: Distress relief only: Cost: $1.3M; New York City health QALYs: 0.43; all-population health QALYs: 0.54. Preserved prior health-only diagnostic, not current combined estimate. {"C":1288400,"N":29129,"z":0.2,"l":1,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0,"r":0.4,"a":0.8,"b":0.6,"g":0.8,"u":0.8,"L":25,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"w":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0,"volunteerCost":0}

Historical alpha diagnostic: No causal health improvement: Cost: $1.3M; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Preserved prior health-only diagnostic, not current combined estimate. {"C":1288400,"N":29129,"z":0.2,"l":1,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0,"r":0.4,"a":0.8,"b":0.6,"g":0.8,"u":0.8,"L":25,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"w":0,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0,"volunteerCost":0}

Historical alpha diagnostic: No benefit plus harm: Cost: $1.3M; New York City health QALYs: -0.40; all-population health QALYs: -0.50. Preserved prior health-only diagnostic, not current combined estimate. {"C":1288400,"N":29129,"z":0.2,"l":1,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0,"r":0.4,"a":0.8,"b":0.6,"g":0.8,"u":0.8,"L":25,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"w":0,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0.5,"volunteerCost":0}

Historical alpha diagnostic: Illustrative volunteer opportunity cost: Cost: $2.2M; New York City health QALYs: 0.93; all-population health QALYs: 1.16. Preserved prior health-only diagnostic, not current combined estimate. {"C":1288400,"N":29129,"z":0.2,"l":1,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"r":0.4,"a":0.8,"b":0.6,"g":0.8,"u":0.8,"L":25,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"w":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0,"volunteerCost":900000}

Historical alpha diagnostic: Half historical marginal hotline allocation: Cost: $1.3M; New York City health QALYs: 0.46; all-population health QALYs: 0.58. Preserved prior health-only diagnostic, not current combined estimate. {"C":1288400,"N":29129,"z":0.2,"l":0.5,"s":0.25,"R":0.002,"e":0.1,"r":0.4,"a":0.8,"b":0.6,"g":0.8,"u":0.8,"L":25,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"w":0.25,"v":0.05,"days":14,"h":0,"volunteerCost":0}

Counterfactual: Free NYC988, other support, grants, covered care and paid leave continue. b controls incremental scale; a clinical advantage; resource incidence is separately net causal differential.

Attribution: Calls are not unique people. Independent episode/household judgments prevent literal contact multiplication. Common-alive utility/resources exclude acute baseline deaths and additional-survivor earnings. Negatives full credit; sequential bases avoid log ledger inconsistency.

Unweighted scenarios, not credible intervals or measured causal next-dollar effects. Outcome/funding/economic priors are judgments; missing other-program effects remain unknown.

Sensitivity

  • Weak additional response and greater cash burden: no finite positive price
  • Stronger response and avoided net pay: 4023820.1796460603
  • No gift-induced expansion: no finite positive price
  • No benefit; health and cash burdens remain: no finite positive price
  • No clinical effect; signed resource effects remain: no finite positive price
  • Existing services remove clinical advantage: no finite positive price
  • No additional deaths averted: 67115102.94279648
  • No additional distress utility improvement: 62892649.195640765
  • No avoided lost pay: 31212019.486172453
  • Positive resource welfare entirely overlaps health: 31212019.486172453
  • Positive cash effect entirely independent: 30295435.415449034
  • Ten contacts per independent crisis: 61493795.966130696
  • Historical reach transfers at half scale: 49195036.77290456
  • Five-year finite survival tail: 47504374.74981182
  • Thirty-day response delay: 30868204.057920087
  • Lower acute episode fatal risk: 51781924.8012465
  • Referral/engagement reduces net disposable pay: 32187001.93995189
  • Selected unrecognized volunteer/public resources: 35195833.79851998
  • Lower household resource reference: 31573540.032250892

Unresolved inputs

  • Unique independent episodes/households and current scale/residency
  • Measured clinical mortality/utility/harms against current988 counterfactual
  • Current grant/capacity response and incremental staffing quote
  • Actual net cash fees, uncovered care and disposable-pay incidence
  • External resource inventory, displacement and unpriced other-program effects

Health and income breakdown

For the modeled $10K: 0.00 health QALYs + 0.00 income-equivalent healthy years in New York City: $3.1M per DALY. Income equivalents are welfare comparisons, not observed QALYs or DALYs.

Method and caveats.

5. Funding and previous grants

Original FY 2025, FY 2024 and FY 2022 returns were freshly retrieved; FY 2023 was not available in the inspected original index, so these are not a consecutive three-year series. FY 2025 audited expense $1,288,400 differs by $1 from Part IX $1,288,399 (program 926,923/management 183,353/fundraising 178,123); direct event expense is blank and is not added. FY 2024 Part IX/audit $1,194,820; FY 2022 Part IX $902,572 plus separately netted direct event $77,785 reconciles to audited gross $980,357. FY 2025 prior-year expense comparator $1,115,933 differs from the FY 2024 original $1,194,820; no comparable mean is forced.

Latest government grants $375,396, revenue $1,002,201, deficit $286,198 and prior-period adjustment−$5,081 accompany ending net assets without restriction $439,448. Cash $283,011, grants receivable $107,596 and accounts receivable $79,916 mean net assets are not cash runway. FY 2024 government grants $370,000 and FY 2022$439,297 are not evidence of uncovered current capacity. Grant renewals, fund restrictions, staffing vacancies, unmet calls and donation replacement remain unknown. No audit opinion/control report was inspected and no donation/contact was made.

Annual expenses

Organization-level spending, including programs, administration and fundraising. The research list averages three comparable, consecutive full fiscal years when available.

  • FY 2022: $980K; Samaritans of New York Inc., 12-month period, July2021–June2022 audit gross; PartIX902572 plus direct event77785; nonconsecutive comparator. Source
  • FY 2024: $1.2M; Samaritans of New York Inc., 12-month period, July2023–June2024 full audit/PartIX; FY2025 comparator differs, unresolved. Source
  • FY 2025: $1.3M; Samaritans of New York Inc., 12-month period, July2024–June2025 audited gross expense; main990 one dollar lower; direct event blank. Source

6. Sources

  1. Original TY2024 Form990, fiscal year July2024–June2025; FY2024-labeled outputs. Samaritans of New York/IRS, hosted by ProPublica. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  2. FY2025 ScheduleD audited reconciliation. Samaritans of New York/IRS, hosted by ProPublica. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  3. Service overview and volunteer hours. Samaritans of New York. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  4. Crisis services and privacy policy. Samaritans of New York. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  5. Crisis hotline outcomes: suicidal callers. Gould et al., Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  6. Mortality after national988 launch. Patel et al., JAMA. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  7. Public988 service. NYC988. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  8. Original FY2024 return. Samaritans of New York / IRS original. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  9. Original FY2022 return. Samaritans of New York / IRS original. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  10. Original FY2022 audit/event reconciliation. Samaritans of New York / IRS original. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  11. Original randomized ASIST counselor training study; indexed primary abstract only in this review. Original operator or research publisher. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  12. Published logarithmic health/income welfare comparison. Original operator or research publisher. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
  13. Operator2023 resources guide updated2024; not observed financial outcome. Original operator or research publisher. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.