Summary
What do they do? Mobilization for Justice provides free civil legal advice and representation to low-income New Yorkers. Its lawyers address eviction, disability benefits, debt collection and workplace barriers, often alongside health and social-service partners. The organization also uses community education and litigation to address barriers that individual advice cannot resolve.
Why we’re interested in this organization:
Housing, benefit and debt assistance can protect practical necessities for people with mental-health disabilities.
A randomized NYC legal-counsel study supports better court outcomes, although it does not measure MFJ health gains.
Benefit and debt assistance can help families preserve the resources needed for ordinary daily life.
Our main reservations:
No controlled MFJ cohort establishes net household resources, sustained health gains or additional outcomes from a new donation.
Government funding, other counsel and a $3.5 million disability-rights grant complicate donor additionality.
Case totals and benefit awards are not unique households or causal welfare gains; household costs and counterparty losses can outweigh benefits.
What do you get for your dollar? $4.4M per DALY in New York City. DALY is our one-year comparison unit. QALY-based health gains and income-welfare equivalents retain their original assumptions; they are not measured clinical DALYs. Full MFJ gross annual recipient expense / conditional adult mental-health stability plus signed net household resources. Other portfolio effects and full social return unknown..
Legal service -> additional stable housing/income/care -> finite psychiatric utility improvement. Household collectible cash/consumption change and service burdens; gross legal claims are not resources.
1. What do they do?
MFJ is one civil legal-aid recipient, EIN 13-2622748, formerly MFY Legal Services. Its services include housing, disability/aging, children and economic justice. Recipient The adult mental-health project is the bounded modeled cohort; other portfolio effects remain unknown. Mental-health services
2. Monitoring and information sharing
Ask for a matched-year unique-household ledger recording housing retained, benefits actually received, collectible debt payments avoided, wages collected and job access sustained, with alternative help and all household costs. A randomized NYC study found better court outcomes with counsel; it measured neither modern MFJ marginal capacity nor QALYs. Original 2001 study The 2023 medical-legal trial reported mixed mental-health and utilization effects, so no trial-derived positive utility coefficient is inserted. Trial
3. Qualitative assessment
Legal representation can retain housing, secure SSI/SSD or public assistance, prevent collectible debt payments and recover wages or remove licensing barriers. Benefits Consumer rights Workplace justice Count actual additional disposable resources after taxes, benefit withdrawal, rent, fees, travel and lost earnings. Debt face values, salary levels and legal victories are intermediate outcomes. Same-household pathways are netted before the logarithmic conversion, and gain/burden cohorts are disjoint. Public benefits are transfers with taxpayer costs; wage settlements and forgiven debt may transfer resources from employers or creditors. This recipient-welfare comparison does not establish net social resource creation; the counterparty and fiscal scenarios test this limitation. Housing scarcity can displace another household and all such unmeasured effects remain unknown. Public counsel baseline
4. What do you get for your dollar?
The reference retains the historical conditional health calculation: 6.14297 NYC-MSA QALYs per annual recipient expense of $25,609,806, or $4.2M per DALY. A separate signed household ledger contributes -0.33641 equivalent healthy years, giving 5.81 combined years and $4.4M per DALY. These are judgment-led conditional scenarios, not measured expected returns. A $1,000 gift scales to 0.0390 additional mental-health service exposures and 0.00215 incremental legal-stability outcomes under the retained capacity assumptions; neither is a promised client or legal win. Resource priors imply 0.00108 gain-household exposures and 0.0372 burden-only exposures per $1,000. Gain households receive a net $1,200 for one year at a $12,000 annual resource baseline; remaining households lose $25, including time/opportunity-cost consumption equivalents. Gains are already net of winner costs. A 50% positive overlap adjustment prevents adding all economic-security welfare to the same psychiatric stability endpoint; negative costs receive full weight. Welfare comparison
Model, assumptions and sensitivity
One year full recipient gross recognized expense including separately netted event direct costs. Current mental-health exposure retained; other portfolio net health provisionally zero, not a whole-portfolio lower bound. Headline is conditional recipient-household welfare: signed counterparty/fiscal welfare remains unknown, not an established zero. Signed household resource welfare is separate from health; donor-recipient expense is not full social cost.
22-county OMB23-01 MSA. g=.98 is a judgment from NYC-focused service, not measured patient residence; test actual addresses before beta.
A=sum(t=1..T) exp(-m*t)/(1+d)^t; Qall=N*z*l*e*r*a*b*u*A-h; Qlocal=g*Qall; price10=10*C/Qlocal when Qlocal>0. Separate income I=.5*sum(disjoint households*discounted finite years*ln((baseline+signed net resources)/baseline)*MSA share*positive overlap share). W=health-only editionQalys+I; headline=10*C/W if W>0, else null. Burden overlap share is always1.
- C
- 25609806 USD (observed). FY ended June 2025 Part IX expense $25,194,864 plus separately netted Part VIII line8b direct event expense $414,942. Schedule D repeats $25,194,864; Part IX explicitly excludes line8b. [mfj99025] [mfjSchedule25]
- N
- 2500 reported annual people (observed). Current program says over2500; use2500. Date/cohort match unknown. [mental]
- z
- 0.8 formula-defined (judgment). 20% haircut for repeat service/intensity ambiguity; source does not measure distinct outcomes.
- l
- 1 formula-defined (judgment). Historical pathway exposure per unrestricted dollar retained; half tested.
- e
- 0.15 formula-defined (judgment). 15% incremental durable legal-stability gain among potentially helped; judgment informed only directionally by legal trials.
- r
- 0.5 formula-defined (judgment). Half remain additional after other providers/public program.
- a
- 0.75 formula-defined (judgment). 75% legal causal share leaves clinical partners credit.
- b
- 0.5 formula-defined (judgment). Half gift causes additional capacity; no current costed funding gap.
- g
- 0.98 formula-defined (judgment). 98% local residence judgment.
- u
- 0.06 formula-defined (judgment). 0.06 annual utility improvement; not a trial-derived mapping.
- T
- 2 years (judgment). Two-year cap, then zero.
- m
- 0.02 formula-defined (judgment). 2% annual competing mortality assumption.
- d
- 0.03 formula-defined (judgment). 3% annual discount.
- h
- 0 formula-defined (judgment). Other-portfolio and displacement net health provisionally zero, adverse tested.
- BaselineResources
- 12000 USD per household-year (judgment). Positive baseline including cash/in-kind; not measured MFJ household income. [mental] [benefits] [consumer] [workplace] [cg]
- NetGain
- 1200 USD per gain household-year (judgment). After taxes, benefit withdrawal, fees, travel and lost earnings; not a measured award. [mental] [benefits] [consumer] [workplace] [cg]
- NetBurden
- -25 USD per remaining household-year (judgment). All costs in unsuccessful/no-gain cases; includes time converted into foregone consumption. [mental] [benefits] [consumer] [workplace] [cg]
- ResourceSuccessShare
- 0.5 fraction (judgment). Half additional stability outcomes have collectible resource effects. [mental] [benefits] [consumer] [workplace] [cg]
- PositiveOverlap
- 0.5 fraction (judgment). Economic welfare not already captured in mental-health stability; no negative-cost discount. [mental] [benefits] [consumer] [workplace] [cg]
- FinancialDuration
- 1 years (judgment). Finite one-year effect; recurrent benefits not automatically capitalized. [mental] [benefits] [consumer] [workplace] [cg]
Conditional stability and signed net household resources: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.34. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
No clinical utility gain; financial ledger persists: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.34. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
No clinical gain; all distinct financial welfare retained: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.32. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":1,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
No additional capacity or induced household exposure: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Clinical harm and no collectible gains: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: -0.98; all-population health QALYs: -1.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: -4.10. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":1,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":100,"resourceShare":0,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Unresolved household resource effects: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":true}
No collectible gains; ordinary burdens remain: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: -1.02. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
10% donor capacity response: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 1.23; all-population health QALYs: 1.25. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.07. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.1,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
75% donor capacity response: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 9.21; all-population health QALYs: 9.40. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.50. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.75,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Complete overlap removes positive income credit: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.99. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
No overlap in independently measured welfare: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.32. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":1,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Six-month resource effect and one-year health benefit: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 3.15; all-population health QALYs: 3.21. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.17. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":1,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":0.5,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Two-year implementation and collection delay: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 5.79; all-population health QALYs: 5.91. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.37. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":2},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":2},"unknown":false}
80% MSA residence allocation: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 5.01; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.27. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.8,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
10% additional partner-resource cost: Cost: $28.2M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.34. {"health":{"C":28170786.6,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Illustrative donor plus incremental fiscal-resource denominator: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.34. {"health":{"C":25643556,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Counterparty welfare offsets all gross positive financial credit: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.99. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":0,"burden":25,"resourceShare":0.5,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Uncalibrated larger net household resources: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: 7.24. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":4800,"burden":25,"resourceShare":1,"overlap":0.5,"years":2,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Heavy household burden erases health reference: Cost: $25.6M; New York City health QALYs: 6.14; all-population health QALYs: 6.27. Income-equivalent healthy years: -10.32. {"health":{"C":25609806,"N":2500,"z":0.8,"l":1,"e":0.15,"r":0.5,"a":0.75,"b":0.5,"g":0.98,"u":0.06,"T":2,"m":0.02,"d":0.03,"h":0,"delay":0},"income":{"baseline":12000,"netGain":1200,"burden":250,"resourceShare":0,"overlap":0.5,"years":1,"delay":0},"unknown":false}
Counterfactual: Existing public representation, other legal aid, psychiatric care and benefits administration persist. e is incremental outcome versus no MFJ among otherwise-addressable clients; r discounts alternative help; a divides legal/clinical partner credit; b captures net extra capacity from gift. Household resources are compared against publicly funded counsel, alternative legal aid, hospital assistance and ordinary benefits administration, not no government support.
Attribution: l=1 preserves the historical mental-health exposure per whole-recipient dollar; it does not earmark all dollars to the project. z deduplicates/intensity-adjusts reported clients; no separate general housing or Medicaid benefit is added. Financial exposure scales once with b and l; positive gain cohort shares e/r/a with incremental stability and is halved by resourceShare. Burden-only exposure is every remaining additional service household, independent of clinical success. No separate earnings, housing subsidy, debt and benefit additions are stacked.
Very weak, judgment-led health conversion and marginal allocation; scenarios are not confidence intervals. Neither the mixed clinical trial nor court-outcome experiment calibrates .06 annual utility or .15 incremental stability. Overlap remains a weak judgment. Delay uses forecast survivors/new intake at service onset, not fixed current persons; no survival through lag is claimed. Financial cohort size, net amounts, baseline and overlap are explicit uncalibrated conditional priors. The reference is not a probability-weighted expected estimate. Clinical-null, financial-only, unknown and negative scenarios are distinct.
Sensitivity
- No clinical utility gain; financial ledger persists: no finite positive estimate
- No clinical gain; all distinct financial welfare retained: $79.9M per DALY
- No additional capacity or induced household exposure: no finite positive estimate
- Clinical harm and no collectible gains: no finite positive estimate
- Unresolved household resource effects: no finite positive estimate
- No collectible gains; ordinary burdens remain: $5.0M per DALY
- 10% donor capacity response: $22.1M per DALY
- 75% donor capacity response: $2.9M per DALY
- Complete overlap removes positive income credit: $5.0M per DALY
- No overlap in independently measured welfare: $4.0M per DALY
- Six-month resource effect and one-year health benefit: $8.6M per DALY
- Two-year implementation and collection delay: $4.7M per DALY
- 80% MSA residence allocation: $5.4M per DALY
- 10% additional partner-resource cost: $4.9M per DALY
- Illustrative donor plus incremental fiscal-resource denominator: $4.4M per DALY
- Counterparty welfare offsets all gross positive financial credit: $5.0M per DALY
- Uncalibrated larger net household resources: $1.9M per DALY
- Heavy household burden erases health reference: no finite positive estimate
Unresolved inputs
- Matched-year distinct mental-health clients, case intensity and psychiatric health outcomes.
- Current unfunded staffing plan and marginal program allocation.
- MSA residence, alternative counsel, public/partner costs and donor substitution.
- Actual net household-resource changes, unsuccessful-case costs and matched unique households; observed missing data do not imply zero.
- Counterparty welfare, displaced tenants, taxes/public benefit costs and unrecognized partner resources.
- Current grant balances, restrictions, costed unfunded staffing and donation-sensitive capacity.
Health and income breakdown
For the modeled $25.6M: 6.14 health QALYs + -0.34 income-equivalent healthy years in New York City: $4.4M per DALY. Income equivalents are welfare comparisons, not observed QALYs or DALYs.
5. Funding and previous grants
FY ended June 2025 gross expense remains the September29 original-return reconciliation: Part IX $25,194,864 plus separately netted event direct cost $414,942 = $25,609,806. Fresh original-return and Schedule D endpoints were inaccessible in this review; this is inherited verified provenance, not a new check. Return The freshly accessed FY2025 annual report states $25,118,398 expense, a distinct unreconciled perimeter. Its 9,848 cases are not unique households. Annual report MFJ announced a $3.5 million disability/aging grant in July2025, a relevant competing funding source rather than proof of extra ordinary-gift capacity. Grant No costed current unfunded plan was established. Ask which additional attorney/paralegal capacity a gift buys, the staffing timeline and restrictions; current annual ratios cannot establish a marginal price. Unrecognized pro-bono/clinical resources, public service use and additional fiscal transfers are unknown and separately stressed; no public savings are credited.
Annual expenses
Organization-level spending, including programs, administration and fundraising. The research list averages three comparable, consecutive full fiscal years when available.
- FY 2024: $22.0M; Mobilization for Justice Inc., 12-month period, June year-end accrual Form990; ScheduleD audited reconciliation. Source
- FY 2025: $25.6M; Mobilization for Justice Inc., 12-month period, June year-end gross recipient recognized expense: Part IX $25,194,864 plus Part VIII8b $414,942. Source
6. Sources
- FY2024 original Form 990 and Schedule D. Mobilization for Justice. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- FY2025 annual report. Mobilization for Justice. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- Mental-health disabilities services. Mobilization for Justice. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- Recipient scope and donation link. Mobilization for Justice. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- Medical-legal partnership randomized trial. Liaw et al., JABFM. Published: 2023-04-07; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- NYC housing-court randomized study. Seron et al., Law & Society Review. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- Evictions Up, Representation Down. NYC Comptroller. Published: 2025-05-02; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- Original TY2024 return, fiscal year July 2024–June 2025. MFJ/IRS, hosted by ProPublica. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- FY ended June 2025 Schedule D reconciliation. MFJ/IRS, hosted by ProPublica. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Government benefits services. Mobilization for Justice. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- Consumer rights services. Mobilization for Justice. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- Workplace justice services. Mobilization for Justice. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- Patterson Belknap disability and aging rights grant. Mobilization for Justice. Published: 2025-07-23; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- Cost-effectiveness welfare comparison. Coefficient Giving. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.
- FY2025 filing summary. ProPublica/IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-05.