Summary
What do they do? CIDNY helps people with disabilities obtain benefits, navigate care and move into community living. It also provides peer mental-health support and advocates for accessibility and disability rights. Our very uncertain, conditional estimate is $59.5 million per 10 NYC-MSA QALYs for the quantified pathways within whole-recipient costs.
Why we’re interested in this organization:
Program-level reporting makes a conservative, unsummed transition cohort identifiable.
Disability-led service delivery addresses practical barriers to using publicly financed care.
Original returns and annual summaries provide a traceable financial baseline.
Our main reservations:
Transition totals conflict and program overlap is unresolved.
Health utility, counterfactual success and marginal funding responsiveness are subjective priors.
Public contracts dominate funding, and broader advocacy outcomes remain unpriced.
What do you get for your dollar? $5.9M per DALY in New York City. DALY is our one-year comparison unit. QALY-based health gains and income-welfare equivalents retain their original assumptions; they are not measured clinical DALYs. Partial clinical reference; household benefits and independent-living resources unknown.
Additional transitions accelerated, actual care access improved, and CBT response beyond alternatives; these map to finite incremental health utility.
1. What do they do?
The charitable recipient is Center for Independence of the Disabled in New York, Inc., EIN 13-2984549, distinct from CIDNY Independent Living Services. Its mix includes navigation, transition coordination, ombudsman work, peer support and policy advocacy. The model retains all functions in the expense denominator. Official program and financial index
2. Monitoring and information sharing
The supplied primary-source audit records 132 Open Doors transitions, 225 Housing Services transitions and a conflicting 387 president's aggregate. We use only 132; none of the others are added. CBT has 27 unique participants, but reported survey improvement is uncontrolled and response-selected. The 65,000 reach claim and assistance contacts are not clinical beneficiaries. The model requests unique IDs across programs, baseline status, actual additional care, six- and twelve-month health measurement, and unsuccessful cases. FY25 report
3. Qualitative assessment
Moving to a preferred community setting can improve autonomy, while navigation can make existing health benefits usable. The national MFP evaluation follows 803 survey completers before and one year after transition; it supports plausibility, but neither a randomized CIDNY effect nor an EQ-5D utility increment. Our 0.05 transition utility is therefore a judgment, not that study's measurement. No disability cure, survival gain or lifetime credit is assumed. Original evaluator description
Benefits and independent-living household resources require targeted assessment; unknown is not zero.
4. What do you get for your dollar?
Household resources are assessed unknown and potentially material. The retained clinical reference remains about $6.0M per DALY for a $1,000 unrestricted gift, using $11,736,265 full annual recipient expense to calibrate output. It is not a complete combined valuation, zero-resource finding or measured 90% health share. Every original clinical world and sensitivity is preserved.
The FY25 annual report identifies cash and food benefits, housing subsidies, disability benefits, utility or moving assistance, coverage appeals and caregiver support. Consumer Services assisted 3,815 households; 599 households completed 826 applications under its NCOA program. These overlapping service cohorts are not additive new benefit recipients. The CHA and ICAN dollar figures are explicitly savings to New York State, not household disposable income. Grocery-card and SNAP recertification examples establish possible resources but not average retained payments. The report records 10 of 53 MyCIL participants obtained employment in the 2021–2025 project, not annual net job creation or net pay. Fifty veterans were served; one 40-hour weekly home-care example establishes possible family-cost relief, not average displaced private spending.
A numerical household bridge needs deduplicated funding-responsive households, realized retained benefits or actual displaced private care/caregiver payments against funded alternatives, net baseline, delay and finite duration. Taxes, withdrawn benefits, rent and utilities, full travel, administration, caregiver time and work costs must be included independently of clinical response. Positive overlap applies only to gains; payer/provider savings and retail service value cannot be credited as household cash or duplicated against original health. Broader benefits, work and independent-living effects remain unquantified, not absent.
The central conditional estimate is $59.5 million per 10 NYC-MSA QALYs (0.00 QALYs per $1,000). For a $1,000 unrestricted gift, annual output-to-whole-expense ratios are scaled by a 0.5 capacity elasticity, then counterfactual success and finite health gains. Central annual-equivalent inputs are 132 transitions, 708 care-navigation consumers and 27 CBT participants; success fractions 0.3/.2/.3, annual utilities 0.05/.02/.05, and durations 1.5/.5/.5 years. Navigation and CBT receive 0.8 and 0.5 residual-overlap multipliers. Mortality is an assumed 5% annually for transitions, 2% navigation and 1% CBT; benefits start after 0.25 years and discount 3%. Additional community time ends when alternatives catch up. Other portfolio net health is zero as a provisional accounting convention, not proof of no benefit or a lower bound. The formula and every scenario override are serialized.
Model, assumptions and sensitivity
$1000 unrestricted donor cost; whole-recipient FY25 annual expense calibrates output scaling. Public treatment/housing expenditures and unrecognized volunteer resources excluded; not full social cost-effectiveness.
g=1 for these modeled five-borough pathways within OMB23-01 NYC MSA; statewide advocacy excluded. This is not all-recipient benefit allocation.
For pathway j: k=ln(1+d)-ln(1-m_j); F_j=exp(-k*lag_j)*(1-exp(-k*T_j))/k (T if k=0). Qall=(D/C)*b*sum(N_j*r_j*u_j*F_j*o_j)-h; Qedition=(D/C)*b*sum(N_j*r_j*u_j*F_j*o_j*g_j)-h*gH. Price10=10*D/Qedition if positive.
- D
- 1000 USD gift (judgment). Ordinary unrestricted gift unit.
- C
- 11736265 USD/year (observed). All-recipient FY25 annual-summary expense. [cidny-fy25]
- b
- 0.5 capacity elasticity (judgment). Half of historical output per dollar survives substitution and marginal capacity limits; no measured fundraising elasticity.
- d
- 0.03 annual discount (judgment). Explicit time preference, sensitivity 0–5%.
- h
- 0.00 QALYs lost per gift (judgment). Other net health provisionally zero; adverse scenario allows loss outside benefit multipliers.
- gH
- 1 MSA harm share (judgment). Modeled adverse harm local.
Central conditional prior: Cost: $1K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. All serialized central inputs and paths.
Low benefit: Cost: $1K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. {"b":0.1,"pathScale":{"r":0.5,"u":0.5,"T":0.5}}
High benefit: Cost: $1K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. {"b":1,"pathScale":{"r":2,"u":2,"T":2}}
Complete funding substitution: Cost: $1K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. {"b":0}
No benefit plus displacement harm: Cost: $1K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. {"b":0,"h":0.001}
Combined resources unknown; clinical reference retained: Cost: $1K; New York City health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Original clinical and full annual calibration scope retained; household resources unknown, not zero.
Counterfactual: Existing contracts, transition subsidies, other navigators and clinical providers continue. r is the fraction whose meaningful outcome is changed versus those alternatives; duration is only time gained before convergence. b removes grant replacement and capacity constraints.
Attribution: b=.5 is marginal output elasticity relative to historical average productivity, not a claimed unrestricted program allocation. Whole-recipient expenditure stays in C. No policy credit added.
Very weak confidence. Source-observed service counts are anchors, not causal effects; r,u,T,b,o and mortality are subjective. Null and negative outcomes are plausible.
Sensitivity
- capacity-low: $29.7M per DALY. {"b":0.1}
- capacity-high: $3.0M per DALY. {"b":1}
- discount-zero: $5.8M per DALY. {"d":0}
- discount-five-percent: $6.0M per DALY. {"d":0.05}
- cost-minus25: $4.5M per DALY. {"C":8802198.75}
- cost-plus25: $7.4M per DALY. {"C":14670331.25}
- transition-N-0.25: $12.4M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"N":33}}}
- transition-N-2: $3.5M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"N":264}}}
- transition-r-0.25: $12.4M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"r":0.075}}}
- transition-r-2: $3.5M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"r":0.6}}}
- transition-u-0.25: $12.4M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"u":0.0125}}}
- transition-u-2: $3.5M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"u":0.1}}}
- transition-T-0.25: $12.2M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"T":0.375}}}
- transition-T-2: $3.7M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"T":3}}}
- transition-o-0.25: $12.4M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"o":0.25}}}
- transition-o-2: $5.9M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"o":1}}}
- transition-zero-effect: $19.5M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"r":0}}}
- transition-high-mortality: $6.2M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"m":0.1}}}
- transition-half-local: $9.1M per DALY. {"paths":{"transition":{"g":0.5}}}
- navigation-N-0.25: $7.5M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"N":177}}}
- navigation-N-2: $4.6M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"N":1416}}}
- navigation-r-0.25: $7.5M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"r":0.05}}}
- navigation-r-2: $4.6M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"r":0.4}}}
- navigation-u-0.25: $7.5M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"u":0.005}}}
- navigation-u-2: $4.6M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"u":0.04}}}
- navigation-T-0.25: $7.5M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"T":0.125}}}
- navigation-T-2: $4.7M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"T":1}}}
- navigation-o-0.25: $7.5M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"o":0.2}}}
- navigation-o-2: $5.6M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"o":1}}}
- navigation-zero-effect: $8.3M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"r":0}}}
- navigation-high-mortality: $6.0M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"m":0.1}}}
- navigation-half-local: $6.9M per DALY. {"paths":{"navigation":{"g":0.5}}}
- cbt-N-0.25: $6.1M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"N":6.75}}}
- cbt-N-2: $5.8M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"N":54}}}
- cbt-r-0.25: $6.1M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"r":0.075}}}
- cbt-r-2: $5.8M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"r":0.6}}}
- cbt-u-0.25: $6.1M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"u":0.0125}}}
- cbt-u-2: $5.8M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"u":0.1}}}
- cbt-T-0.25: $6.1M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"T":0.125}}}
- cbt-T-2: $5.8M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"T":1}}}
- cbt-o-0.25: $6.1M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"o":0.125}}}
- cbt-o-2: $5.8M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"o":1}}}
- cbt-zero-effect: $6.1M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"r":0}}}
- cbt-high-mortality: $6.0M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"m":0.1}}}
- cbt-half-local: $6.0M per DALY. {"paths":{"cbt":{"g":0.5}}}
Unresolved inputs
- Deduplicated cohorts and counterfactual outcomes
- Marginal unrestricted staffing responsiveness
- Validated health utility and follow-up
- FY24/25 original financial reconciliation
- Deduplicated funding-responsive households with realized retained benefits or actual private-payment displacement, net resource baseline, alternative providers, taxes and withdrawn benefits, full access/caregiver burdens and finite timing.
5. Funding and previous grants
Annual-summary FY2023/2024/2025 expenses are $8,937,955/$9,831,086/$11,736,265, a descriptive mean of $10,168,435.33. Latest expense includes program $10,283,988, management $1,349,456 and fundraising $102,821. Original FY2023 Form 990 confirms $8,937,955; FY2022 original shows $8,292,256. The website's '2024' return is an image PDF not successfully read here: three original comparable recent returns are NOT verified. FY2023's annual-summary stale footnote is superseded for that amount by its original return. FY24/25 remain annual-report financial approximations. FY25 government contracts $9,643,944 and veterans revenue $1,656,969 make full gift additionality implausible without a staffing constraint; 0.5 elasticity is deliberately contestable. Public care and housing costs are outside donor costs. FY2023 original return
Annual expenses
Organization-level spending, including programs, administration and fundraising. The research list averages three comparable, consecutive full fiscal years when available.
- FY 2023: $8.9M; Center for Independence of the Disabled in New York, Inc., 12-month period, annual-report accrual summary (FY23 original return corroborated). Source
- FY 2024: $9.8M; Center for Independence of the Disabled in New York, Inc., 12-month period, annual-report accrual summary (FY23 original return corroborated). Source
- FY 2025: $11.7M; Center for Independence of the Disabled in New York, Inc., 12-month period, annual-report accrual summary (FY23 original return corroborated). Source
6. Sources
- FY2025 annual report. CIDNY. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-08.
- FY2023 annual report. CIDNY. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Original FY ended June 2023 Form 990, Part I line18. CIDNY / IRS filing. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Original FY ended June 2022 Form 990, Part I line18. CIDNY / IRS filing. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Original return link; image PDF not read, no financial corroboration claimed. CIDNY. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Change in Participant Experience During First Year of Community Living. Mathematica / CMS evaluation. Published: 2011-05-30; retrieved: 2026-09-29.