Summary
What do they do? FernCare Free Clinic provides no-cost non-emergency primary care to uninsured adults in Ferndale, Michigan. Volunteer clinicians offer medications, basic laboratory testing and help applying for insurance. Its current clinic schedule runs monthly, and its 2025 fundraising appeal reports more than 1,988 patient visits.
Why we’re interested in this organization:
Volunteer clinicians provide uninsured adults with primary care, medicines and testing. Appropriate treatment can improve symptoms and reduce preventable disease.
Three latest accessible original IRS returns support the whole-recipient recorded-cost boundary.
The model distinguishes visits from people, current activity from old residence evidence, and average from marginal benefit.
Our main reservations:
The verified current output is visits, not unique patients or completed treatment episodes. Current residence, clinical improvement, donated-resource valuation and added capacity per dollar remain unresolved.
Obtain a current completed-care cohort and cost reconciliation, then a specific expansion or preservation budget with staffing, volunteer capacity, alternative funding and metro-resident reach. A randomized clinic-specific outcome study is not required to reopen an alpha.
Recorded costs exclude unreconciled donated resources; even the volunteer sensitivity is incomplete economic cost.
What do you get for your dollar? Illustrative $77K per DALY under a historical annual-average scenario; the return from a new donation is not established.
>1,988 reported visits and >3,500 volunteer hours in 2025; not primary-verified unique completed care courses.
1. What do they do?
FernCare operates in Ferndale and offers no-cost non-emergency care, generic medications, basic laboratory testing and insurance-enrollment assistance. Its current patient page includes a 2026 clinic schedule. The current dinner appeal reports eight clinic sessions monthly; the undated About page still says six, so the newer dated activity disclosure takes precedence.
Detroit-Warren-Dearborn MSA, OMB July 2023 boundary: Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, Livingston, Lapeer and St. Clair. Ferndale is within Oakland County. Current local beneficiary share is not known; the clinic also advertises statewide access. Ann Arbor/Washtenaw, Flint/Genesee, Monroe and Windsor are outside.
2. Monitoring and information sharing
Current official service and fundraising pages; IRS BMF row; Givebutter recipient match: Current clinic schedule and active fundraising identify the recipient at 751 E Nine Mile Road, Ferndale. Establishes current operations and recipient, not effectiveness or funding room.
Three original IRS e-file renders and Schedule O: 2024 revenue $187,710, line17 expense $206,882, net assets $46,345; 2023 $147,698/$185,319/$65,517; July2021–June2022 $177,538/$209,195/$107,674. Includes a fiscal-year transition and prior-period adjustments; not three directly comparable calendar years. Gross fundraising costs netted against revenue are $254/$8,736/$6,737 respectively.
2019 original clinic review: Distinct patient and appointment denominators are explicitly separated. Residence was overwhelmingly Oakland, Wayne and Macomb. Useful historical evidence; does not establish 2025 completed-care counts or present local share.
Ettehad et al. randomized-trial meta-analysis: A 10 mm Hg systolic blood-pressure reduction was associated with major cardiovascular-event RR 0.80 in included trials. Supports treatment plausibility. FernCare's achieved BP change, baseline risk, treatment duration and adherence are unknown. It does not supply q = 0.003.
Oregon randomized Medicaid lottery study: Coverage increased access and reduced depression, while several measured physical-health outcomes did not significantly improve. Insurance coverage differs from a free clinic. More contacts alone are not a validated QALY conversion; null outcomes remain credible.
3. Qualitative assessment
Volunteer clinicians provide uninsured adults with primary care, medicines and testing. Appropriate treatment can improve symptoms and reduce preventable disease.
Current completed unique-patient courses, condition mix and outcome follow-up were not primary-verified. 2024 expense and 2025 visits/hours are different periods; the alpha openly uses a normalization assumption. FY2023 Schedule O includes $14,998 prior-period adjustment; FY2022 has -$4,273 bookkeeper in-kind adjustment. No smooth financial trend or simple in-kind addback is justified. Original filings are primary IRS data rendered by ProPublica, not audited financial statements. Latest three accessible filings were inspected; no recent independent audit was located. Website pages differ about clinic frequency and eligible age/underinsurance. Use current patient instructions operationally; reconcile historical tax prose before describing broad eligibility.
No numerical coefficient is empirically identified. Calling it conservative describes author intent, not an established lower bound.
4. What do you get for your dollar?
The scenario combines the latest inspected original spending year (2024) with verified 2025 visits. It assumes that these approximately describe one operating year; a 0.9–1.5 cost multiplier tests the mismatch but does not reconcile it. The visit coefficient is an explicit conservative judgment prior informed by clinical plausibility, not a study estimate. We do not invent a unique-patient count or infer complete courses from visits.
Q = V × a × m × q − H; recorded-spending cost per 10 = 10C / Q, if Q > 0. V = 1,988; C = $207,136; a = 0.50; m = 0.90; q = 0.00 net QALY per visit-equivalent; H = 0 in the illustrative base. Q = 2.6838. Total resource C* = C + unbooked volunteer time + unbooked medicines/labs/facilities + induced care costs, without double counting. Marginal donor Q(G) is a separate unknown function.
~$77K per DALY on recorded spending; ~$142K with 3,500 volunteer hours at an illustrative $50/hour, before other omitted costs. The base is conditional, not calibrated expected value.
Whole-recipient historical expenses are verified, but reported volunteer hours and historically donated drugs show that cash spending understates total inputs. Current medicine/lab donations and their accounting treatment are unpriced. Historical 2019 or 2020 in-kind values must not simply be added to 2024 expense. The $300 patient sponsorship and $3,000 clinic sponsorship include event benefits and are fundraising descriptions, not marginal contracts.
Model, assumptions and sensitivity
Whole-recipient historical expenses are verified, but reported volunteer hours and historically donated drugs show that cash spending understates total inputs. Current medicine/lab donations and their accounting treatment are unpriced. Historical 2019 or 2020 in-kind values must not simply be added to 2024 expense. The $300 patient sponsorship and $3,000 clinic sponsorship include event benefits and are fundraising descriptions, not marginal contracts.
Detroit-Warren-Dearborn MSA, OMB July 2023 boundary: Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, Livingston, Lapeer and St. Clair. Ferndale is within Oakland County. Current local beneficiary share is not known; the clinic also advertises statewide access. Ann Arbor/Washtenaw, Flint/Genesee, Monroe and Windsor are outside.
Q = V × a × m × q − H; recorded-spending cost per 10 = 10C / Q, if Q > 0. V = 1,988; C = $207,136; a = 0.50; m = 0.90; q = 0.00 net QALY per visit-equivalent; H = 0 in the illustrative base. Q = 2.6838. Total resource C* = C + unbooked volunteer time + unbooked medicines/labs/facilities + induced care costs, without double counting. Marginal donor Q(G) is a separate unknown function.
- V: completed patient visits
- "1,988 activity floor for 2025" visits (observed). 2026 annual-dinner letter reports patient visits. No inference that these are unique people, fully completed chronic-care courses or visits added by a new donor. Range: Official claim exceeds 1,988 [s1]
- C: whole-recipient recorded spending
- "$207,136" USD (observed). $206,882 line 17 plus $254 line 6c. Keep overhead and all recipient activity in the numerator. Do not turn the site's $300 annual-service sponsorship menu into a marginal procurement quote. Range: $186,422–$310,704 for 0.9–1.5 period/cost sensitivity [s4]
- a: care additionality versus alternatives
- "0.50" as described (judgment). Uninsured access barriers support some additionality; Medicaid/ACA enrollment, other free clinics and alternative providers reduce it. This is not measured donation additionality. A second donor funding multiplier would be needed for a marginal model. Range: 0.20–0.80 positive scenarios; zero also possible [s2] [s10]
- m: local health share
- "0.90" as described (judgment). 2019 clinic review reports 45.1% Oakland, 35.4% Wayne and 17.2% Macomb residence (97.7% sum; rounded). This is not a current share. Statewide eligibility and telehealth justify reducing the base and retaining broad sensitivity. Range: 0.70–0.98 positive scenarios; geographic null possible [s8]
- q: overlap-adjusted health per visit-equivalent
- 0.00 QALY QALY per visit-equivalent (judgment). About 1.1 quality-adjusted days per visit-equivalent, averaged across useful treatment and low-benefit follow-up. Interpret as total net course benefit allocated across its visits, never repeated lifetime credit per visit. This small prior reflects symptom relief and prevention plausibility; trials support some clinical pathways but do not identify this coefficient. No extra QALYs are added for labs, prescriptions or referrals. Range: 0.0005–0.010 in positive scenarios; zero and negative possible [s9] [s10]
- Unbooked volunteer resource value
- "3,500 × $50 = $175,000 illustrative add-on" as described (judgment). Official appeal reports more than 3,500 hours in 2025. Rate, role mix, overlap with booked costs and opportunity cost require reconciliation. These scenarios use the reported hour floor, not a measured full economic cost. Range: $105,000–$350,000 at $30–$100/hour [s1]
- Additional capacity purchased by next gift
- "No numerical estimate" as described (unknown). An appeal and past deficits establish fundraising, not a staffed marginal expansion or preservation counterfactual. Do not extrapolate the annual-average model linearly to a large gift. Range: May be zero [s1] [s3]
Marginal donor return unknown — HOLD: Cost: unknown; Detroit health QALYs: unknown; all-population health QALYs: unknown. No priced incremental service package or current capacity counterfactual; scenario ratios below are not the expected return on a donation.
Conditional recorded-spending illustration: Cost: $207K; Detroit health QALYs: 2.68; all-population health QALYs: 2.98. 1988 × 0.50 × 0.003 all-population QALYs; multiply 0.90 local share. 2024 cost normalized to 2025 activity; all clinical factors assumed.
Illustrative volunteer-inclusive cost: Cost: $382K; Detroit health QALYs: 2.68; all-population health QALYs: 2.98. Add 3500 hours × assumed $50, subject to overlap reconciliation. Remaining omitted resources unpriced.
Favorable positive stress case: Cost: $186K; Detroit health QALYs: 15.59; all-population health QALYs: 15.90. C × .9, a .8, m .98, q .010; not a probability interval.
Unfavorable positive stress case: Cost: $311K; Detroit health QALYs: 0.14; all-population health QALYs: 0.20. C × 1.5, a .2, m .7, q .0005; not a probability interval.
Null health: Cost: $207K; Detroit health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Zero effective treatment benefit or care additionality. Separately, donor funding displacement can imply zero marginal benefit.
Additional harm stress test: Cost: $207K; Detroit health QALYs: -1.32; all-population health QALYs: -1.02. Additional H=4.00 QALYs wholly local subtracted from gross base all-population 2.982 and local 2.6838; purely illustrative harm test. Ordinary expected harms already belong in q. Display loss, no negative price.
Counterfactual: Care additionality prior 0.50 is separate from unknown donor funding additionality. The next gift may replace existing financing and add no health.
Attribution: Whole recipient recorded spending in numerator; local conditional care benefit only. No separate benefits for prescriptions, tests, referrals or community services.
Positive scenarios are not probabilities, confidence intervals or proof of marginal donor value. There is no primary-verified current annual unique completed-care cohort in this review. A secondary social mirror says 841 unique patients in 2025; it is not used in the model. Donor recommendation and quantified funding room stay HOLD/null.
Sensitivity
- Illustrative base: ~$77K per DALY on recorded spending. V 1,988; C $207,136; a 0.50; m 0.90; q 0.003; no separately modeled harm. Health is a prior-based scenario, not observed.
- Favorable positive scenario: ~$12K per DALY. 0.9 × recorded cost, a 0.80, m 0.98, q 0.010. This combines favorable assumptions and excludes omitted resources; it is not a confidence bound.
- Unfavorable positive scenario: ~$2.2M per DALY. 1.5 × recorded cost, a 0.20, m 0.70, q 0.0005. The broad range shows how little the clinical conversion is identified.
- Volunteer resource sensitivity: ~$116K–$208K per 10 at base health. Add 3,500 hours at $30–$100/hour to recorded spending, subject to overlap reconciliation. Medicines, discounted laboratories and induced downstream costs remain additional unknowns.
- Null: No finite cost per DALY. If effective care additionality or health improvement is zero, Q = 0. Independently, a gift replacing other funding may produce zero marginal benefit even when current services help.
- Adverse: Net health loss is possible. If adverse events/displaced care exceed gross benefit, Q < 0. Report harm rather than a negative cost-effectiveness ratio. Base q should already deduct ordinary expected treatment harms; H is a stress test for additional unaccounted harm.
Unresolved inputs
- Current distinct completed treatment courses, condition mix, outcomes and metro residence.
- Matched-year whole-recipient paid and donated resource reconciliation.
- Specific incremental or preserved service budget, staffing and volunteer capacity, alternate funding and funding room.
5. Funding and previous grants
Positive scenarios are not probabilities, confidence intervals or proof of marginal donor value. There is no primary-verified current annual unique completed-care cohort in this review. A secondary social mirror says 841 unique patients in 2025; it is not used in the model. Donor recommendation and quantified funding room stay HOLD/null.
Obtain a current completed-care cohort and cost reconciliation, then a specific expansion or preservation budget with staffing, volunteer capacity, alternative funding and metro-resident reach. A randomized clinic-specific outcome study is not required to reopen an alpha.
The donation page uses $250/$2,500 examples; the newer event appeal uses $300/$3,000 and event tickets. Neither establishes marginal delivery. No causal benefits are assigned to the other community-resource activities, and no claim of whole-portfolio lower bound is made.
Annual expenses
Organization-level spending, including programs, administration and fundraising. The research list averages three comparable, consecutive full fiscal years when available.
- FY 2024: $207K; FernCare Free Clinic Inc, 12-month period, Original IRS Form 990-EZ line 17; direct event costs netted in revenue excluded. Period/calendar transition and prior adjustments prevent comparable mean.. Source
- FY 2023: $185K; FernCare Free Clinic Inc, 12-month period, Original IRS Form 990-EZ line 17; direct event costs netted in revenue excluded. Period/calendar transition and prior adjustments prevent comparable mean.. Source
- FY 2022: $209K; FernCare Free Clinic Inc, 12-month period, Original IRS Form 990-EZ line 17; direct event costs netted in revenue excluded. Period/calendar transition and prior adjustments prevent comparable mean.. Source
6. Sources
- 2026 annual-dinner appeal and sponsorships. FernCare Free Clinic. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Become a Patient / 2026 schedule. FernCare Free Clinic. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Monetary Donations. FernCare Free Clinic. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- 2024 Form 990-EZ, object 202531369349201128. IRS via ProPublica. Published: 2025-05-16; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- 2023 Form 990-EZ, object 202431369349202658. IRS via ProPublica. Published: 2024-05-15; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- July2021–June2022 Form 990-EZ, object 202341369349201389. IRS via ProPublica. Published: 2023-05-16; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Michigan Exempt Organization Business Master File. IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- 2019 Clinic Review. FernCare Free Clinic. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Blood pressure lowering for prevention of cardiovascular disease and death. Ettehad et al. / The Lancet. Published: 2016-03-05; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- The Oregon Experiment—Effects of Medicaid on Clinical Outcomes. Baicker et al. / NEJM. Published: 2013-05-02; retrieved: 2026-09-29.