Summary
What do they do? KIND provides dental care to low-income Colorado children through clinics and school visits. Its clinics offer preventive, restorative and specialized treatment, including general anesthesia when needed. Chopper Topper delivers school screening, sealants and fluoride, while community apprentices help families navigate care.
Why we’re interested in this organization:
New original2024 report separates967clinicpatients,6246schoolchildren and8920sealants from visits and outreach.
Original dental studies support prevention and relief mechanisms without claiming measured KIND utility.
The model keeps child health separate from caregiver household grouping and jointly nets full access burdens and signed resources.
Our main reservations:
Sealants divided by four are tooth-equivalents, not unique protected children; retention, tooth types and clinical benefit remain judged.
Whole recipient cost against selected pathways is incomplete portfolio coverage, not a verified next-gift opportunity.
Exact school/clinic household overlap, actual cash savings, local residence and usable checkout remain unmeasured.
What do you get for your dollar? $1.1M per DALY in Denver. DALY is our one-year comparison unit. QALY-based health gains and income-welfare equivalents retain their original assumptions; they are not measured clinical DALYs. Conditional matched2024 full annual recipient cost against school-sealant and clinic symptom-relief health equivalents plus signed caregiver resources; not measured pediatric QALYs, calibrated wholeportfolio EV or marginal-gift price..
The original2024 impact report page5 reports967clinicpatients,1832clinicvisits,6246schoolchildren,8920sealants and5735community interactions. The headline12948 is the sum of different units, not a deduplicated treated cohort. Page7 describes new surgical-site capacity and80%uninsured among an unspecified group needing surgical restoration, not among all967patients. Unique restored teeth, completed treatment plans, permanent-molar fraction, reapplications and retention are unavailable. Page11 describes ten paid apprentices and two Community Dental Health Worker certifications, not causal employment or net wage gains. Track pain/function, treatment completion, repeat children, county residence and household expenditures separately.
1. What do they do?
KIND provides dental care to low-income Colorado children through clinics and school visits. Its clinics offer preventive, restorative and specialized treatment, including general anesthesia when needed. Chopper Topper delivers school screening, sealants and fluoride, while community apprentices help families navigate care. Current eligibility is low-income children through age18, including Medicaid, CHP+ and Delta Dental. These coverage options and other dental providers are explicit alternatives, not proof that KIND adds no care.
2. Monitoring and information sharing
The original2024 impact report page5 reports967clinicpatients,1832clinicvisits,6246schoolchildren,8920sealants and5735community interactions. The headline12948 is the sum of different units, not a deduplicated treated cohort. Page7 describes new surgical-site capacity and80%uninsured among an unspecified group needing surgical restoration, not among all967patients. Unique restored teeth, completed treatment plans, permanent-molar fraction, reapplications and retention are unavailable. Page11 describes ten paid apprentices and two Community Dental Health Worker certifications, not causal employment or net wage gains. Track pain/function, treatment completion, repeat children, county residence and household expenditures separately.
3. Qualitative assessment
The Griffin original US school model supplies .00159DALYs per four-first-molar child-equivalent over four years, already discounted3%; tooth-equivalent scaling, transport .75, substitute-care attribution .75 and health-unit equivalence1 remain judgments. The schema field editionQalys stores health-only equivalents, not observed validated pediatric QALYs. A randomized104-child dental rehabilitation study found better oral-health-related quality of life after general anesthesia but no improvement in dental fear. An85-dyad uncontrolled study measured CHU9D raw-score improvement2.48, not a0–1utility difference or integratedQALY gain. FiCTION randomized1144children with asymptomatic primary-molar decay and found no overall pain/sepsis difference between restoration, biological management and prevention over33.8months. Therefore the clinic channel assumes half of967patients have relevant symptoms and half receive additional relief versus alternate care; .012healthy-year-equivalent/year for three months is a judgment anchored to Griffin toothache severity, not a transferred causal utility estimate. Positive clinic benefit is reduced20% for possible sealant/pain overlap; negative losses are not erased.
4. What do you get for your dollar?
Use original FY2024 IRS full annual expense$1,879,713 against2024 activity. Relevant netted event lines are blank; no addback or sponsor gross-up is applied. The annual report instead presents$1,941,320 expenses, an unresolved$61,607 discrepancy tested separately; its grant timing note concerns revenue and does not reconcile costs. Three-year mean remains$1,658,785. Current health2.173946625 and signed resource-equivalent years−.5261407516 imply$1.1M per DALY, versus the historical$818K sealant-only illustration; the old production price was null, not a ranked central estimate. This difference mixes cost/output vintage changes, clinic hypotheses and full household burdens, not observed effectiveness deterioration. Fullrecipient cost still includes outreach, education and apprenticeship with effects unquantified, so this selected-channel reference is not wholeportfolio EV. No allocated sealant/clinic cost is source-verified. Retained2023 sealant-only scenario isolates the original numerical diagnostic.
Model, assumptions and sensitivity
Use original FY2024 IRS full annual expense$1,879,713 against2024 activity. Relevant netted event lines are blank; no addback or sponsor gross-up is applied. The annual report instead presents$1,941,320 expenses, an unresolved$61,607 discrepancy tested separately; its grant timing note concerns revenue and does not reconcile costs. Three-year mean remains$1,658,785. Current health2.173946625 and signed resource-equivalent years−.5261407516 imply$1.1M per DALY, versus the historical$8.2M sealant-only illustration; the old production price was null, not a ranked central estimate. This difference mixes cost/output vintage changes, clinic hypotheses and full household burdens, not observed effectiveness deterioration. Fullrecipient cost still includes outreach, education and apprenticeship with effects unquantified, so this selected-channel reference is not wholeportfolio EV. No allocated sealant/clinic cost is source-verified. Retained2023 sealant-only scenario isolates the original numerical diagnostic.
g=.9 retains judged ten-county Denver MSA residence, not clinic/headquarters location. Boulder, Greeley and Colorado Springs excluded.
School=(S/4)*D*T*A*K; clinic=clinicN*symptomatic*clinicAdded*q*years with positive-only health overlap; full process harms subtracted; localhealth*g*discount(delay). Resource households partitioned and joint same-year net flows logged: .5*HH*log(after/before)*g*discount. Price10=10*C/(health+signedresources).
- C
- 1879713 USD/year (observed). Observed FY2024 original IRS fullrecipient expense; matched2024 activity. Annualreport accounting differs and is a sensitivity. [cost24]
- S
- 8920 sealants/year (observed). Observed8920sealants in2024, not8920uniquechildren or verified permanent first molars. [native24]
- schoolN
- 6246 observed children/patients per year (observed). Observed6246schoolchildren in2024; cohort dedup across clinic unverified. [native24]
- clinicN
- 967 observed children/patients per year (observed). Observed967clinicpatients in2024, not967restorative completions or GA cases. [native24]
- D
- 0.00159 model parameter (judgment). External already-four-year-discounted .00159DALY model per four-first-molar child; transport/scaling remain unvalidated. [bridge]
- T
- 0.75 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- A
- 0.75 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- K
- 1 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- g
- 0.9 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- symptomatic
- 0.5 model parameter (judgment). Judged half of clinicpatients eligible for symptom-relief channel; surgical80%uninsured is not applied to everyone.
- clinicAdded
- 0.5 model parameter (judgment). Judged half of symptomatic patients obtain additional relief beyond Medicaid/other care; FiCTION supports strong-alternative sensitivity.
- q
- 0.01 healthy-year-equivalent per symptomatic year (judgment). Judged .012 annual toothache-equivalent severity, not CHU9D2.48 utility or measured KINDQALY. [bridge]
- years
- 0.25 model parameter (judgment). Judged three-month additional pain relief; study follow-up is not measured causal benefit duration.
- healthOverlap
- 0.8 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- schoolHarm
- 0.00001 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- clinicHarm
- 0.0001 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- unique
- 0.8 model parameter (judgment). Resourcehouseholdconversion only; does not reduce distinct children clinical count.
- baseline
- 20000 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- clinicGain
- 50 model parameter (judgment). Judged50USD net actually avoided paid care plus after-tax/benefit-adjusted caregiver work; separate accesscost30 not subtracted twice. Not retail services or child wages.
- schoolGain
- 0 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- positiveOverlap
- 0.5 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- clinicCost
- 30 model parameter (judgment). Judged30USD NET additional travel/time/fees versus alternate care for all exposed clinic household equivalents; not gross travel costs or benefit-scaled losses. Zero-additional-cost sensitivity explicit.
- schoolCost
- 1 model parameter (judgment). Judged1USD NET additional consent/access burden for free onsite care; not parent clinic travel or cost already incurred without KIND.
- payerLossFraction
- 0 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- externalCost
- 0 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- payerPeople
- 10000 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- payerBaseline
- 50000 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- r
- 0.03 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
- delay
- 0 model parameter (judgment). Explicit conditional judgment; not measured KIND causal utility, net resources, overlap or resident distribution.
central: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
clinical null: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: -0.14; all-population health QALYs: -0.16. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
financial only: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.43. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
failed benefits full burdens: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: -0.14; all-population health QALYs: -0.16. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.64. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
no exposure: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
no gift no exposure: Cost: $0; Denver health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
adverse: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: -0.80; all-population health QALYs: -0.88. Income-equivalent healthy years: -1.07. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
unknown: Cost: unknown; Denver health QALYs: unknown; all-population health QALYs: unknown. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
sealants only health: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.74; all-population health QALYs: 1.93. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.11. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
clinic only: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 0.44; all-population health QALYs: 0.48. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.41. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
no restorative added benefit: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.65; all-population health QALYs: 1.84. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.64. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
all clinic symptomatic: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.70; all-population health QALYs: 3.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.42. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
few clinic symptomatic: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.86; all-population health QALYs: 2.07. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.59. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
one month relief: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.83; all-population health QALYs: 2.03. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
one year relief: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 3.74; all-population health QALYs: 4.16. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
small utility hypothesis: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.83; all-population health QALYs: 2.03. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
negative clinic overlap zero: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.00; all-population health QALYs: 1.11. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
negative clinic overlap one: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.00; all-population health QALYs: 1.11. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
half DALY QALY bridge: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.28; all-population health QALYs: 1.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
no valid bridge: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 0.38; all-population health QALYs: 0.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
lower retention transport: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.10; all-population health QALYs: 1.22. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
strong other dental care: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 0.56; all-population health QALYs: 0.62. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.61. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
full local: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.42; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.58. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
half local: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 1.21; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.29. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
no local: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
household dedup half: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.33. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
disjoint resource cohorts: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
full resource overlap: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
no otherwise paid resources: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.64. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
higher net caregiver resources: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.20. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
negative resource overlap zero: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -1.07. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
negative resource overlap one: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -1.07. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
no school participation cost: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.41. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
no additional access cost: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.11. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
high clinic access burden: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -1.75. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
full copay counterparty loss: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.61. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
outside provider cost: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.75. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
annual report cost: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
three year cost: Cost: $1.7M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
unrecorded full resource cost: Cost: $2.2M; Denver health QALYs: 2.17; all-population health QALYs: 2.42. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.53. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
one year delay: Cost: $1.9M; Denver health QALYs: 2.11; all-population health QALYs: 2.35. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.51. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
retained 2023 sealant diagnostic: Cost: $1.5M; Denver health QALYs: 1.88; all-population health QALYs: 2.09. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. Conditional matched2024 fullrecipient cost and school/clinic output envelope; not wholeportfolio empirical EV or marginal gift. Sealant DALY/QALY scaling and clinical symptom/utility/attribution/duration, resource households/flows/costs/local share are judgments. Full negative burdens survive failed benefits; positive overlap only.
Counterfactual: Medicaid, CHP+, insurance, other dental clinics and prevention; added care is not identical to a newgift funding share. School screening/referrals and clinic relief may overlap.
Attribution: The Griffin original US school model supplies .00159DALYs per four-first-molar child-equivalent over four years, already discounted3%; tooth-equivalent scaling, transport .75, substitute-care attribution .75 and health-unit equivalence1 remain judgments. The schema field editionQalys stores health-only equivalents, not observed validated pediatric QALYs. A randomized104-child dental rehabilitation study found better oral-health-related quality of life after general anesthesia but no improvement in dental fear. An85-dyad uncontrolled study measured CHU9D raw-score improvement2.48, not a0–1utility difference or integratedQALY gain. FiCTION randomized1144children with asymptomatic primary-molar decay and found no overall pain/sepsis difference between restoration, biological management and prevention over33.8months. Therefore the clinic channel assumes half of967patients have relevant symptoms and half receive additional relief versus alternate care; .012healthy-year-equivalent/year for three months is a judgment anchored to Griffin toothache severity, not a transferred causal utility estimate. Positive clinic benefit is reduced20% for possible sealant/pain overlap; negative losses are not erased.
Conditional hypotheses, not confidence intervals or empirically calibrated EV. Fullrecipient cost/partialhealth scope and unvalidated DALY/QALY equivalence persist; resource and clinic pathways can be null or adverse.
Sensitivity
- Historical2023 sealant-only diagnostic reproduces8.1797M; it was not a ranked production price.
- Three-month clinic relief uses judgment .012healthy-year-equivalent, not observed CHU9D utility; one-month/one-year and clinical-null cases bound it.
- Full burdens persist under failed benefits; negative clinical/resource flows are not overlap-discounted.
- Annualreport versus IRS expenses, whole-economic-cost stress, payer loss and disjoint household overlap are explicit.
- Access costs mean net additional costs versus alternate care, not gross travel; no-additional-access-cost case tests zero.
Unresolved inputs
- Unique children, tooth type, reapplication and sealant retention
- Denver MSA residence ZIP/county split
- Pediatric QALY utility mapping and outcomes versus usual care
- Current funding room, capacity and reimbursement response
- Verified donation checkout and receipt identity
- Reconciliation of annual-report and IRS accounting expense
- Actual symptomatic/completed clinic cohort and additional pain duration
- After-tax caregiver resources, actual copays and payer/provider incidence
- Program-allocated costs and economic effects of paid apprenticeship
Health and income breakdown
For the modeled $1.9M: 2.17 health QALYs + -0.53 income-equivalent healthy years in Denver: $1.1M per DALY. Income equivalents are welfare comparisons, not observed QALYs or DALYs.
5. Funding and previous grants
The official website links Classy, redirecting to give.kindsmiles.org/give/275386. Current retrieval identifies a solicitation but cannot read checkout fields or final receipt identity; no transaction occurred and donor HOLD remains. The2024 surgical-site launch suggests a mechanism for avoiding unfamiliar referrals, not verified current marginal staff capacity or a priced funded treatment. Medicaid, insurance, other clinics and free prevention create replacement-funding and provider alternatives. Caregiver net resources are not retail free dentistry: a judged$50 per additional symptomatic-care household combines actually avoided out-of-pocket spending and after-tax/benefit-adjusted caregiver work, before separately subtracting full$30 NET additional travel/time/fees versus counterfactual care. Positive gains alone receive .5 overlap. School care is onsite/free; only a judged$1 NET additional consent/access cost is applied, not clinic travel to all6246families. Household conversion .8 is separate from patient health. Central assumes clinic households are a subset of school households for joint logs; disjoint case tests unknown overlap. Distinct payer/provider loss and unrecognized resource-cost scenarios are explicit; recognized donated services are not added twice. Ten paid apprentices and other family channels remain economically unknown, not proven zero.
Annual expenses
Organization-level spending, including programs, administration and fundraising. The research list averages three comparable, consecutive full fiscal years when available.
- FY 2022: $1.6M; Kids In Need of Dentistry, 12-month period, Original IRS Form 990 Part IX plus netted Part VIII direct resource costs; securities basis excluded. Source
- FY 2023: $1.5M; Kids In Need of Dentistry, 12-month period, Original IRS Form 990 Part IX plus netted Part VIII direct resource costs; securities basis excluded. Source
- FY 2024: $1.9M; Kids In Need of Dentistry, 12-month period, Original IRS Form 990 Part IX plus netted Part VIII direct resource costs; securities basis excluded. Source
6. Sources
- 2024 original IRS Form 990 rendered from e-file. Kids In Need of Dentistry / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- 2023 original IRS Form 990 rendered from e-file. Kids In Need of Dentistry / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- 2022 original IRS Form 990 rendered from e-file. Kids In Need of Dentistry / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- 2023 impact report, PDF page 3; printed pages 4–5. Kids In Need of Dentistry. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Chopper Topper current services. Kids In Need of Dentistry. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Clinical services. Kids In Need of Dentistry. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Official home and donation link. Kids In Need of Dentistry. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Historical Give a Smile Today appeal. Kids In Need of Dentistry. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Sealants for preventing tooth decay in permanent teeth. Cochrane. Published: 2017-07-31; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Sealants for preventing tooth decay in baby teeth. Cochrane. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- Griffin et al. School-Based Dental Sealant Programs Prevent Cavities And Are Cost-Effective. Health Affairs / CDC manuscript repository. Published: 2016-12-01; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- FiCTION three-arm randomized trial. NIHR Health Technology Assessment. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-29.
- 2024 original impact report; pages5,7,11,18. Kids In Need of Dentistry. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-07.
- Randomized pediatric dental rehabilitation and oral quality of life. Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology / PubMed. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-07.
- Prospective dental treatment: CHU9D raw score and family outcomes. International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry / PubMed. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-07.
- Health and logarithmic income comparison framework. Coefficient Giving. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-07.