GiveBetter x California

Walk San Francisco

Street safety implementation advocacy, school access and crash-survivor support

Research time: ~5 min on GPT-6 Astra Light + ~9 min on GPT-6.1 Sol
  • Research — reviewed programs, finances and impact evidence.
  • Modeling — estimated costs, QALYs and uncertainty.

Updated: 2026-10-02

Donate

Summary

What do they do? Walk San Francisco advocates for safer streets and supports people affected by traffic crashes. Its campaigns seek more protective street designs, safer school routes, and stronger public safety policy. Community organizing and Families for Safe Streets connect residents and survivors with the city's decision-making process.

Why we’re interested in this organization:

  • Physical traffic calming has credible external injury evidence and a direct route to improving health.

  • A focused local advocacy program can help prioritize high-risk streets and connect community concerns to agency decisions.

  • Original recent financial returns and current agency plans make costs and the public baseline inspectable.

Our main reservations:

  • No named project and costed additional workplan establish how an extra donation changes implementation.

  • Advocacy influence, future casualty exposure, victim prognosis, and net household-resource gains remain uncertain.

  • The conditional estimate quantifies only selected street-safety pathways; school, survivor, accessibility, and wider policy effects remain unquantified.

What do you get for your dollar? $87.8M per DALY in California. DALY is our one-year comparison unit. QALY-based health gains and income-welfare equivalents retain their original assumptions; they are not measured clinical DALYs. Conditional partial physical-safety and household-resource portfolio estimate.

Additional early exposure to physical street-safety design; fatal and severe nonfatal injuries avoided; finite survival and impairment benefit; one-off preserved net household resources among baseline-alive nonfatal victims. Meetings, total city crash changes, public construction budgets and camera speeding counts are not new gift outcomes.

1. What do they do?

The recipient is Walk San Francisco Foundation, EIN 47-2000881, not the city agency constructing streets. Its portfolio includes street-design/policy advocacy, school walking programs, community organizing and Families for Safe Streets. The official impact page provides giving links and original returns; the third-party checkout could not be opened in this review. Current portfolio and financial source index

Current Slow Our Streets work seeks traffic-calming designs, safer limits and enforcement. Thirty-three speed-camera locations are already operating. Their historical implementation and observed speeding changes are not benefits created anew by today's ordinary gift. Current Slow Our Streets campaign

The 2025 report describes continued work on city implementation and potential expansion of camera authority, along with survivor support. These are plausible distinct pathways; only a hypothetical physical traffic-calming acceleration is quantified here. No restricted-best-program donation is assumed. 2025 Impact Report, published June 2026

2. Monitoring and information sharing

SFMTA reports 25 traffic deaths in 2025, compared with 43 in 2024. This citywide change is not a causal estimate for Walk SF or for a new gift. 2025 traffic fatality count SFDPH's assessment describes roughly 550 severe traffic injuries per year historically since 2014; it is not a 2025 injury count. The model's paired 25/550 baseline is deliberately labeled constructed. 2024 Community Health Assessment, historical severe-injury context

Grundy and colleagues analyzed London 20 mph zones with physical traffic-calming using a controlled interrupted time series. Overall casualties fell about 42%; restricting analysis to 2000–06 yielded smaller estimates, including about 28% for killed/seriously injured. Death-specific precision was weak. The study adjusted underlying trends and examined nearby roads; it was not randomized and does not prove the same effect for modern San Francisco, speed-limit signs or education alone. Controlled interrupted time series of London 20 mph zones

Meaningful monitoring links a named street package to baseline casualty exposure, a with-gift and without-gift opening date, implemented design, displaced traffic and actual casualties. Meetings, supporters, surveys and adopted resolutions are not substitute health outcomes. Check independent agency plans and co-advocate accounts before assigning contribution.

The current recalibration uses the original London full-text XML obtained through Europe PMC. It supports physical engineering, not an empirical advocacy coefficient. Neither before/after camera speeding nor citywide fatality changes establish the effect of new donations.

3. Qualitative assessment

Current agency evidence supports a real participation role without establishing sole credit. September 2026's draft Safe School Connections plan names Walk SF among multiple partners, describes public capital and existing Safe Routes resources, and seeks final approval in late 2026/early 2027. Its long-term reach requires additional staff and finance. This is a live implementation context, not a verified Walk SF funding gap or the model's identified package. Safe School Connections draft approach, September 2026

Survivor support and a more accessible walking environment can be valuable beyond counted physical injuries. They remain unquantified rather than assumed absent. Conversely, street changes require review of emergency access, disability access, diverted traffic, enforcement burdens and opportunity cost; a successful advocacy campaign is not automatically a net health gain.

California includes San Francisco and the rest of the state. People injured on San Francisco streets can live elsewhere, so the model assumes 98% California benefit rather than equating crash location with residence. This is an explicit prior, not measured victim geography; no statewide camera-policy spillover is added.

4. What do you get for your dollar?

GiveBetter estimates approximately $87.8M per DALY for the physical street-safety health and household-resource pathways quantified here. This conditional calculation is not a verified donation opportunity or a complete valuation of Walk SF's portfolio. A DALY means one modeled equivalent year; income equivalence compares welfare, not measured clinical QALYs.

What does funding support? Donations support advocacy, organizing and survivor-related work rather than directly buying city construction. The model normalizes additional funding against FY2025 gross recipient expenses of $992,695, judges that half produces additional activity and half of that activity concerns physical-safety advocacy. It then assigns a conditional influence factor of 0.25 to that annual-effort unit. None of these fractions is measured marginal influence. An illustrative $100,000 corresponds to about 2.52% of an annual advocacy-effort unit before influence; it is not a quoted staffing tranche.

What could that work achieve? A hypothetical disjoint package covering 1% of city casualty risk opens half a year earlier, after a 1.5-year preparation delay. Only the earlier exposure window counts; baseline public work subsequently catches up. Physical design is assigned 10% net fatality reduction and 20% severe-injury reduction, below several external engineering estimates but still judgment-dependent. The historical city baseline of 25 fatalities and roughly 500 severe nonfatal injuries is not a project-specific forecast. The model implies about 0.0000787 fatal events and 0.003148 severe nonfatal events avoided per illustrative budget.

Health and income. Fatal injury prevention uses a finite 30-year survival trajectory, utility 0.8, annual competing mortality 2%, and a 3% discount rate. The duration is retained as an unvalidated continuity judgment, not measured victim prognosis; shorter-horizon cases remain. Nonfatal impairment is valued at 0.1 utility for one year. A fixed 30% positive clinical-overlap allocation remains unchanged when resource gains switch sign or become zero; a coexistence case shows both outcomes without that exclusion. These assumptions produce 0.00 California health years.

For 30% of avoided severe nonfatal injuries, the resource model assumes one baseline-alive household preserves $2,500 net resources once, against $50,000 annual baseline resources. This covers plausible work loss or private costs after taxes, sick pay, insurance and benefit offsets—not baseline earnings for extra survivors or public spending. Timing and the separate California share give 0.00 income-equivalent years.

Why the estimate changed. The historical illustration was $444K per DALY. It assumed a $100,000 gift had a 10% chance of moving a package covering 2% of city casualty risk two years earlier. Those package assumptions were not established. The current model scales influence to recipient-wide annual advocacy effort and uses a smaller, shorter acceleration window, while adding household resources explicitly. This changes the model's unit and judgments, not observed organizational effectiveness. Marginal influence remains the decisive uncertainty; the approximately 198-fold difference should not be read as a measured deterioration.

Current city plans and already-operating cameras remain the counterfactual, not benefits purchased anew. Associated construction/maintenance resources are separate from donor cost. Source-vetted project schedules, casualty exposure, a costed additional workplan and recipient outcome data are needed before treating this as donor-ready. Other school, survivor, accessibility and policy pathways are unquantified and may matter materially.

Model, assumptions and sensitivity

Entire recipient donor budget, proportionally normalized to latest gross annual expenses. Half the additional portfolio effort is assigned to physical-safety advocacy; all other costs remain charged. Associated public capital is a separate resource sensitivity, never donor cash or household income.

Central health and household-resource shares are independently 98% California, allowing for visitors. The share is a residence judgment, not observed casualty geography. No duplication across SF/Bay/California donations or population/headquarters multiplier.

scale=gift/expense*funding*advocacyShare; additional risk exposure-years=scale*influence*riskShare*acceleration. Fatal and nonfatal events avoided feed separate finite health trajectories discounted from the acceleration-window midpoint. Distinct net nonfatal household receipts use 0.5*people*log(1+receipt/baseline). Price=donor cost/(California health+income equivalent years+signed independent burden), only for positive total.

gift
100000 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
expense
992695 USD gross annual expense (observed). FY2025 original Form 990 functional expenses plus separately netted direct event costs, not a marginal donor quote. [99025]
funding
0.5 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
advocacyShare
0.5 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
influence
0.25 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
riskShare
0.01 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
acceleration
0.5 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
openingDelay
1.5 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
annualFatalities
25 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). The observed 2025 all-traffic count was 25; applying it to future exposure is a forecast judgment, not an observed future rate. [fatal]
annualSevere
500 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
fatalReduction
0.1 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
severeReduction
0.2 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
survivalUtility
0.8 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
survivalYears
30 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
hazard
0.02 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
injuryUtility
0.1 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
injuryYears
1 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
resourceShare
0.3 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
clinicalOverlapShare
0.3 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
netReceipt
2500 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
baseline
50000 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
healthCA
0.98 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
incomeCA
0.98 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
burdenCA
1 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
assignment
1 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
discount
0.03 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
fee
0 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
inducedHouseholds
0 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
inducedLoss
0 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
independentHealthHarm
0 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
capital
1000000 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.
maintenance
20000 Model parameter; see formula and cost discussion (judgment). Explicit planning judgment, not a measured marginal causal coefficient; named cases expose material uncertainty.

Conditional partial-portfolio central: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Low Influence: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.05,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

High Influence: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.5,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Low Risk: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.002,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

High Risk: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.03,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Quarter Year: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.25,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

One Year: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":1,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Mean Expense: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":947639.3333333334,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Zero Income: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":0,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Zero Health: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Resource Loss: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":-2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Injury Harm: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":-0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Fatal Harm: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":-0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

No Funding: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

No Influence: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

No Assignment: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":0,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

No C A: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0,"incomeCA":0,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Failed Induced: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.01. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":10,"inducedLoss":100,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Assignment Induced: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: -0.01. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":0,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":10,"inducedLoss":100,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Independent Harm: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: -0.10; all-population health QALYs: -0.10. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0.1,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Income25 K: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":25000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Income100 K: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":100000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Health Only Full Cohort: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Physical Cash Coexistence: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Fees: Cost: $103K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":30,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0.03,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Five Year Survival: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":5,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Ten Year Survival: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":10,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Twenty Year Survival: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"expense":992695,"funding":0.5,"advocacyShare":0.5,"influence":0.25,"riskShare":0.01,"acceleration":0.5,"openingDelay":1.5,"annualFatalities":25,"annualSevere":500,"fatalReduction":0.1,"severeReduction":0.2,"survivalUtility":0.8,"survivalYears":20,"hazard":0.02,"injuryUtility":0.1,"injuryYears":1,"resourceShare":0.3,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.3,"netReceipt":2500,"baseline":50000,"healthCA":0.98,"incomeCA":0.98,"burdenCA":1,"assignment":1,"discount":0.03,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"capital":1000000,"maintenance":20000}; current expense and historical city fatality context do not identify marginal influence, future package risk or household incidence. Unweighted cases are not confidence bounds.

Historical hypothetical-package calculation: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.23; all-population health QALYs: 0.23. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"p":0.1,"b":0.02,"F":25,"S":550,"eF":0.1,"eS":0.2,"start":2,"delay":2,"uF":0.8,"hazard":0.02,"TF":30,"uS":0.1,"TS":3,"gCA":0.98,"r":0.03,"K":1000000,"M":20000,"H_CA":0}

Counterfactual: Existing capital, already-operating cameras, agency staff and other advocates continue. Credit only net physical protection delivered earlier or improved by the added work. Positive annual exposure ends when baseline implementation catches up; injuries already avoided retain finite later health.

Attribution: Funding response, advocacy allocation and conditional influence are distinct planning judgments applied once. A disjoint hypothetical package represents 1% of city casualty risk, not 1% of street length. Fatal and nonfatal cases are separate. Household resources concern baseline-alive nonfatal victims; no extra-survivor wage stream. Fixed positive clinical overlap allocation is independent of income sign, with coexistence sensitivity; negative health and independent induced burdens are retained.

Conditional partial physical-safety portfolio estimate, not complete organizational EV, a lower bound, an empirical confidence interval or a verified donor tranche. The old hypothetical package did not establish donor influence; tying expense to annual advocacy effort changes the unit but does not identify causality. Missing project-specific evidence can materially change either sign or magnitude.

Sensitivity

  • Current conditional estimate is $87.8M per DALY, combining 0.00 California health years and 0.00 income-equivalent years per illustrative $100,000. The old hypothetical-package health illustration was $444K, not a validated giving opportunity.
  • Funding response, advocacy share, influence, disjoint risk share and acceleration determine additional exposure. Vary them separately rather than stacking unexplained generic attribution discounts.
  • Thirty-year finite survival and the 2% annual competing hazard remain unvalidated continuity judgments; 5/10/20-year cases disclose the tail rather than replacing it with an unsupported abrupt cutoff.
  • Income zero/negative cases hold clinical overlap fixed. Coexistence removes the overlap exclusion while keeping both pathways. All cases are unweighted, not statistical confidence bounds.
  • Independent induced household losses and health harms persist when positive funding/influence/assignment is null. Donor fees affect donor cost; associated engineering resources affect a separate resource-cost comparison.

Unresolved inputs

  • Named package, disjoint casualty exposure and no-gift implementation date.
  • Costed additional charitable work and evidence of marginal coalition/agency influence.
  • Current age, victim residence, severe nonfatal definitions and post-injury utility trajectories.
  • Net household losses, insurance/sick-pay offsets, earnings duration and distinct recipient incidence.
  • Net accessibility, traffic displacement, school, survivor-support and broader policy effects.

Health and income breakdown

For the modeled $100K: 0.00 health QALYs + 0.00 income-equivalent healthy years in California: $87.8M per DALY. Income equivalents are welfare comparisons, not observed QALYs or DALYs.

Method and caveats.

5. Funding and previous grants

Original accrual Form 990 functional expenses were $863,052, $921,193 and $981,449 for June-ending fiscal years 2023–2025. Separately netted event costs are added to the gross spending comparison below. Original FY 2023–24 Form 990 with prior-year comparative

The 2025 return allocates $513,353 to programs, $252,527 to management/general and $215,569 to fundraising. Revenue is $894,475, including $198,441 government grants. Net assets are $885,931, with $50,000 restricted. These original figures do not establish present spare capacity or an unfunded advocacy tranche. The return indicates compiled/reviewed statements, not an independent financial audit. Original FY 2024–25 Form 990

The public construction counterfactual is substantial. SFMTA's May 2026 capital update says its planned improvements reach 62% of the High Injury Network. It already has funded quick-build and other safety projects. A donation could change timing/design, but cannot claim all existing planned benefits. Current planned street-safety capital projects

The June 2026 Safety Zone initiative also includes an already-approved Community Corners program. Its existence updates older descriptions of pending daylighting commitments; do not treat an approved agency initiative as a new philanthropic purchase. Safety Zone program and Community Corners approval

Before relying on the estimate, ask for a costed staffing or organizing increment, the exact agency bottleneck, project risk exposure, capital availability and expected opening date without the new work. Financial deficit alone does not answer those questions.

For a consistent gross-spending comparison, the annual figures add direct event costs netted against revenue: $39,957 in FY 2023, $26,021 in FY 2024 and $11,246 in FY 2025. Gross totals are therefore $903,009, $947,214 and $992,695; their mean is $947,639.33. These organizational size figures do not change the separate gift-based health calculation.

Annual expenses

Organization-level spending, including programs, administration and fundraising. The research list averages three comparable, consecutive full fiscal years when available.

  • FY 2023: $903K; Walk San Francisco Foundation,EIN47-2000881, 12-month period, Accrual Form 990 functional expenses plus direct fundraising-event costs netted against revenue; June-ending fiscal year, gross expense basis.. Source
  • FY 2024: $947K; Walk San Francisco Foundation,EIN47-2000881, 12-month period, Accrual Form 990 functional expenses plus direct fundraising-event costs netted against revenue; June-ending fiscal year, gross expense basis.. Source
  • FY 2025: $993K; Walk San Francisco Foundation,EIN47-2000881, 12-month period, Accrual Form 990 functional expenses plus direct fundraising-event costs netted against revenue; June-ending fiscal year, gross expense basis.. Source

6. Sources

  1. Current Slow Our Streets campaign. Walk San Francisco. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  2. Current portfolio and financial source index. Walk San Francisco. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  3. 2025 Impact Report, published June2026. Walk San Francisco. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  4. Original FY2024–25 Form990. Walk San Francisco Foundation. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  5. Original FY2023–24 Form990 with prior-year comparative. Walk San Francisco Foundation. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  6. 2025 traffic fatality count. SFMTA. Published: 2026-01-08; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  7. 2024 Community Health Assessment, historical severe-injury context. SF Department of Public Health. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
  8. Controlled interrupted time series of London20mph zones. Grundy et al., BMJ. Published: 2009-12-10; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  9. Current planned street-safety capital projects. SFMTA. Published: 2026-05-05; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  10. Safe School Connections draft approach, September2026. SFMTA. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
  11. Safety Zone program and Community Corners approval. SFMTA. Published: 2026-06-17; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  12. Original FY 2022–23 Form 990, including separately netted event costs. Walk San Francisco Foundation. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
  13. Folsom Streetscape public funding plan and construction schedule. SFMTA. Published: 2026-08-04; retrieved: 2026-09-30.