Summary
What do they do? The Berkeley Center for Independent Living helps people with disabilities live in their communities. It lends and repairs mobility equipment, helps make homes accessible, and offers benefits counseling, peer support and other independent-living services. These services can restore daily function and reduce out-of-pocket costs for Northern Alameda County residents.
Why we’re interested in this organization:
Equipment repair and loaners address a concrete barrier to everyday mobility.
Free services and home-access support can help people who cannot obtain equivalent assistance elsewhere.
Original annual accounts and primary studies allow us to examine costs, alternative services and plausible benefits separately.
Our main reservations:
Current additional repair capacity, unique completed cases and functional days restored are not measured in the public evidence.
The repair estimate depends on judgmental utility and household-savings assumptions; other CIL programs could materially change the overall result.
The original FY2025 audit remained inaccessible, so the exact prior control findings and their remediation are not verified.
What do you get for your dollar? $14.6M per DALY in California. DALY is our one-year comparison unit. QALY-based health gains and income-welfare equivalents retain their original assumptions; they are not measured clinical DALYs. Conditional ordinary-gift repair and household-resource estimate; full gift cost retained, other CIL services not quantified. Not a verified additional funding offer..
Illustrative $100,000 ordinary funding: support-loaded episode $450.39; 4.440568 additional unmet-function episodes; 62.167958 function-days; 0.888114 separate counterfactual-purchaser households. Central health 0.005069201 + resources 0.001759633 California equivalent years. These are modeled, not observed outputs.
1. What do they do?
CIL serves Northern Alameda County residents through a broad independent-living portfolio. It is the Berkeley charity with EIN 23-7175191, not the similarly named Corporation for Independent Living at cil.org. Its current service pages offer loans of wheelchairs, ramps and other equipment as inventory permits, with a repair-request route. This is evidence of delivery capability, not an assured inventory or turnaround time. Current programs and Northern Alameda County service area Assistive technology loaners and repairs
Home-access work includes modifications such as ramps and grab bars. Berkeley's publicly funded program is distinct from nearby cities, where CIL says lack of funding limits it to consultations. A gift might enable otherwise-unfunded modifications, but no priced expansion plan establishes that an unrestricted gift would go there. Residential access and geographic funding gap
CIL offers free demonstrations and is also a licensed Whill vendor. Separate purchased powerchairs from donated devices and free loaners; sales capability does not establish sales volume or donated-service outcomes. Whill sales and demonstrations
2. Monitoring and information sharing
The most useful repair measure is additional person-days with a safely functioning device compared with the actual alternative: vendor repair, insurance, another loaner, self-repair or going without. Record request and completion dates, device fit and use, recurrent failures, outside repair availability and resulting health/function. Repeat repairs for one person must not each receive an entire lifetime benefit. Assistive technology loaners and repairs
The attendant registry prioritizes high-risk people when provider supply is scarce. Matching information is not itself paid care, filled hours or prevented institutionalization. CIL should measure additional sustained care hours and health outcomes, including cases where the limiting resource is a worker rather than coordination money. Personal attendant services and limited provider registry
Original returns provide financial detail but broad, partly historical program descriptions rather than current cohort outcome data. The audit index flags FY2023/FY2024 internal-control weaknesses. The underlying audit download was unavailable in this review, so neither the exact finding nor its resolution is independently established here; this is a follow-up item, not a finding of fraud. Filing and audit index
The city’s draft FY2025 CAPER reports seven CIL-supported rental accessibility projects. These are publicly supported outputs, not additional donor-caused health.
September 30 update: a FY2025 audit is indexed, but the original auditor report remained inaccessible. No exact finding, audit opinion or remediation is newly verified. Absence of an index warning does not establish resolution of prior control weaknesses.
October 2 reassessment rechecked the three original returns and current service pages. The original FY2025 auditor download returned an access error; no new audit opinion or remediation finding was established. A month to respond is not completion time. A useful additional ledger would pair unique completed repairs with counterfactual function-days and net household payments, while separating publicly funded or otherwise available services.
3. Qualitative assessment
A multicenter observational wheelchair study found frequent repairs and adverse consequences, including being confined at home; another reported median repair time of 14 days. These document a meaningful problem, but they do not estimate the causal effect of CIL repair or a health-utility decrement. Vendor users may differ in severity, device complexity and resources. Factors influencing wheelchair repairs and consequences Wheelchair repairs: delays, causes and associated outcomes
Other branches have credible external evidence. The HIPI randomized home-modification trial estimated an adjusted reduction in home fall injuries, with a crude estimate whose interval included no effect. Its New Zealand households and modification package are not interchangeable with CIL's client mix or every ramp installation. HIPI home modification cluster-randomized trial
Living Well was evaluated with a randomized wait-list design in 246 consumers across independent-living centers. Results support some improvement in secondary conditions and health-related outcomes. The investigators' later synthesis says symptom days returned to baseline by twelve months and health costs by two months; neither perpetual savings nor lifelong QALYs are justified. CIL currently offers the curriculum, but delivery fidelity, additional enrollment and local results remain unknown. Health promotion: evaluation of Living Well with a Disability Living Well with a Disability: intervention and follow-up synthesis Living Well Senior Program
Independence, access and dignity are important even when incompletely measured by QALYs. Disability status is not a discount on a person's worth; any quantitative benefit should be a change in their experienced health or function, not an assumption that disability makes a life less valuable.
4. What do you get for your dollar?
GiveBetter estimates approximately $14.6M per DALY for a conditional repair-and-household-savings pathway. A DALY here means one modeled equivalent year in California. This is a partial planning estimate, not a price for a confirmed donation opportunity or a complete assessment of CIL's work.
What does money buy? The illustrative calculation allocates 10% of ordinary additional funding to repair and loaner services. A support-loaded attempted episode costs about $450, based on assumed staff time, employment costs, materials and organization support. After allowing for funding replacement, completion and equivalent alternatives, each $100,000 of ordinary funding corresponds to about 4.44 additional restored-function episodes, totaling 62.17 otherwise-lost functional days, plus 0.89 separate households avoiding a $100 payment. These are modeled yields, not CIL-reported output counts or a $100,000 funding request. The full gift remains in the cost calculation, including the 90% supporting services not quantified here.
We think the repair mechanism matters because a functioning wheelchair, walker or temporary loaner can let someone move around and participate in daily life while another device is unavailable. But CIL's month-long response queue is not evidence of a month of function restored. The external survey's fourteen-day median among completed repairs is only a time-scale anchor; the actual gain must be measured against vendor, insured, public loaner and backup options. CIL repair and loaner services Primary repair survey
Health and household resources. The central calculation gives 0.01 health years and 0.00 income-equivalent years per illustrative $100,000. Unmet-access recipients receive the temporary health credit; people who would otherwise purchase timely equivalent service receive only net household savings, not duplicate health credit. The $100 one-off saving, 10% purchaser share and $25,000 household-resource baseline are explicit assumptions, not observed invoices or client income. They are distinct from the $100 materials allowance. Additional paid work and caregiver resources are examined in signed scenarios, with no positive central earnings assumption. Public/insurer expenditure and unpaid time are not automatically household income. Income-to-health comparison
What changed? The historical repair illustration was $5.9M per DALY. The revised central is $14.6M: the temporary utility judgment falls from 0.10 to 0.03 to align with the mixed adult-mobility mechanism, while separately adding household savings. Neither utility is a measured CIL effect. The shared 0.03 prior is a consistency judgment, not independent confirmation; severe-dependence cases may warrant more. The new calculator uses a 3% annual discount convention and preserves the old continuous-3% calculation separately.
Removing savings gives about $19.7M; retaining 0.10 utility with the new savings gives about $5.4M. Household-resource baselines, function-days, allocation, completion, funding replacement, utility, burdens and original-audit follow-up remain decisive uncertainties. The scenarios are not confidence intervals.
Other pathways. Home access, benefits navigation, Living Well, institutional transitions, peer support and advocacy are not assigned zero value. An outside-Berkeley modification scenario tests a separate budget and nonoverlapping cohort, but the stated funding gap does not establish a priced additional project. Original studies support some home-safety and independent-living mechanisms, not CIL-specific effect sizes. Donated equipment, volunteers and public shipping also have resource costs not fully priced here. Residential access
Model, assumptions and sensitivity
Ordinary unrestricted gift, C=$100,000 analytical normalization. Full gift remains charged even though this model quantifies only a repair/loaner health pathway. f is an explicit marginal portfolio allocation, not a restricted donation. Unit cost k includes wages, employment loading, materials and allocated recipient support. This is donor-dollar cost, not a societal-cost estimate; donated device and partner resource opportunity costs remain unknown.
g_CA=1 for the short-duration direct-service scenario, based on Northern Alameda County eligibility. National advocacy benefits are not counted. This is an inference about weeks of local client benefit, not location of headquarters.
calculate() in lib/cil-ca-calibrated-model.mjs. Support-loaded cost → funding/completion/deduplicated episodes → disjoint unmet-function and counterfactual-purchaser cohorts. Finite health and paid-work integrals use log1p(annual discount); one-off savings use the Coefficient Giving log-resource crosswalk. Separate clinical, income, burden and geography components are added once. The original continuous-discount illustration is frozen separately.
- gift
- 100000 USD ordinary gift (judgment). Calculation normalization; not a verified funding request.
- repairAllocation
- 0.1 ordinary gift share supporting repair/loaner capacity (judgment). A modest share within a broad portfolio. Core consumer services includes AT along with housing, home modification and transitions; repair-only allocation is not reported. Stress 0.02–0.25. The allocated share includes its corresponding support costs; k is therefore support-loaded, not a second charge to the total gift. [99025] [repairs]
- wage
- 34 USD direct wage/hour (judgment). Rounded proxy from current $33.99/hour community independent-living specialist vacancy; not a verified repair technician wage. General CIL careers page states starting pay $28/hour. Stress $28–40. [cil-job-specialist] [cil-jobs]
- benefitLoad
- 1.35 employment-cost multiplier on wage (judgment). 35% benefits/payroll/paid-leave loading; CIL advertises extensive benefits but actual marginal load is unreported. Stress 1.2–1.5. [cil-jobs]
- hours
- 4 staff hours per attempted episode (judgment). Intake, handling, repair or loaner preparation, fitting and closeout combined. No local time-motion study; stress 2–8 hours. [repairs] [cil-at]
- materials
- 100 USD materials per attempted episode (judgment). Average repair/cleaning/component allowance, not device retail price or CIL observed invoice. Stress $50–500; actual case mix could exceed this.
- supportLoad
- 1.5881269038170636 recipient support-loading factor (judgment). Central proxy equals observed total/program expense ratio 1.5881269; applying average support loading to marginal service cost is a judgment. Stress 1.3–2, not an accounting confidence bound. [99025]
- funding
- 0.5 financial/capacity additionality (judgment). Half the modeled allocation adds usable service capacity after grant/reserve replacement and staffing constraints. Public grants are large, while requests and volunteer needs suggest unmet demand. Stress 0.1–0.8 plus zero. [99025] [cil-at]
- completion
- 0.8 completed appropriate-function fraction (judgment). Repair/loaner can fail or be unsuitable. External SCI repair survey's completion data motivate uncertainty, not a measured CIL success rate. Stress 0.5–0.95. [cil-repair-study-full]
- dedup
- 1 unique nonoverlapping episode fraction (judgment). One modeled unique household per episode; repeated function-days and repeated savings require deduplication. No observed deduplication rate. [repairs]
- unmetShare
- 0.5 fraction beating equivalent timely alternatives (judgment). Half successful episodes deliver function otherwise lost after allowing insurance/vendors, state loan centers, EDI and backups. Stress 0.1–0.9. [repairs]
- purchaserShare
- 0.1 fraction of completed unique households (judgment). 0.10 judgmental counterfactual purchaser stratum, disjoint from the 0.50 unmet-function stratum. No observed purchase incidence. [repairs]
- functionDays
- 14 functional days gained per truly additional episode (judgment). Finite acceleration prior, not observed days saved. External survey median repair duration was 14 days; CIL reports roughly one month before responding, so its current service is not automatically faster. Stress 2–60 days. [repairs] [cil-repair-study-full]
- utility
- 0.03 temporary health-utility change (judgment). 0.03 mixed adult-mobility family prior replaces 0.10. Neither is measured CIL utility; the cross-sectional repair survey does not identify a generic decrement. [repair-study]
- delay
- 0.25 years before gained function begins (judgment). Central quarter-year implementation/queue delay; stress 0.05–0.5.
- discount
- 0.03 annual discount rate (judgment). 3% annual convention; continuous-time finite benefits use log1p(rate). Historical continuous3% remains frozen. [cil-cg]
- netCash
- 100 USD one-off net household saving (judgment). Avoided repair/copay/rental payment after offsets, not materials cost or measured invoice. Zero and negative cases retained. [repairs] [cil-cg]
- baseline
- 25000 USD annual household resources (judgment). 25,000 planning judgment, not measured client income; 50,000 and100,000 tested separately. [cil-cg]
- earnerShare
- 0 fraction of unmet-function households (judgment). Zero central paid-work incidence; optional20% judgment does not create an observed employment effect. [cil-benefits]
- annualNetWork
- 3000 USD annualized net paid-resource change (judgment). Optional signed work/caregiver resource scenario; only finite function-days counted, no positive central work incidence. [cil-benefits] [cil-cg]
- clinicalOverlapShare
- 0 fixed reserved positive clinical fraction (judgment). Zero central overlap because purchasers are disjoint. Optional work cases reserve20% independently of earnings sign; adverse utility is not reduced. [repairs]
- homeAllocation
- 0 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- homeCost
- 5000 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- homeCompletion
- 0.8 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- homeUnmetShare
- 0.8 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- homeIndependent
- 1 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- homeUtility
- 0.02 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- homeYears
- 2 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- homeDelay
- 0.5 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- assignment
- 1 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- healthCA
- 1 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- incomeCA
- 1 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- burdenCA
- 1 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- fee
- 0 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- inducedHouseholds
- 0 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- inducedLoss
- 0 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- independentHealthHarm
- 0 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- externalPerAttempt
- 0 Model parameter; definitions in formula and source memo (judgment). Conditional planning assumption; observed financial ratio and wage anchor do not establish marginal cost, actual recipient incidence or causal outcomes. See cil-ca-recalibration-2026-10-02.md. [repairs] [99025] [cil-cg]
- FY2025 total expenses
- 4370584 USD/year (observed). Original return Part IX recipient total; retained financial scale. [99025]
- FY2025 program expenses
- 2752037 USD/year (observed). Original Part IX program column; not a repair-only budget. [99025]
Current conditional central: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
historical Clinical: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.02; all-population health QALYs: 0.02. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.1,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
zero Cash: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":0,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
zero Health: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
no Funding: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
no Assignment: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":0,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
no C A: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":0,"incomeCA":0,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
cash Loss: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":-100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
health Harm: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: -0.01; all-population health QALYs: -0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":-0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
all Harm: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: -0.01; all-population health QALYs: -0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":-0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":-100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
failed Induced: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":10,"inducedLoss":25,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
assignment Induced: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":0,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":10,"inducedLoss":25,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
independent Harm: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: -0.09; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0.1,"externalPerAttempt":0}
full Replacement: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0,"purchaserShare":0,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
low Gap: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.01,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
high Gap: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.02; all-population health QALYs: 0.02. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.1,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
short Gap: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":2,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
long Gap: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.02; all-population health QALYs: 0.02. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":60,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
low Funding: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.1,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
high Funding: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.8,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
low Allocation: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.02,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
high Allocation: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.25,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
dedup Half: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":0.5,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
no Completion: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
purchaser Zero: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
income50 K: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":50000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
income100 K: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":100000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
work Positive: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0.2,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.2,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
work Zero Fixed Cohort: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0.2,"annualNetWork":0,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.2,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
work Negative: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0.2,"annualNetWork":-3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0.2,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
work Coexists: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0.2,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
outside Berkeley Modifications: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.03; all-population health QALYs: 0.03. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0.1,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
home Null: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0.1,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
home Harm: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: -0.02; all-population health QALYs: -0.02. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0.1,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":-0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
support13: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.3,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
support20: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.00; all-population health QALYs: 0.00. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":2,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
fees: Cost: $103K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0.03,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":0}
external Resources: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.01; all-population health QALYs: 0.01. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"gift":100000,"repairAllocation":0.1,"wage":34,"benefitLoad":1.35,"hours":4,"materials":100,"supportLoad":1.5881269038170636,"funding":0.5,"completion":0.8,"dedup":1,"unmetShare":0.5,"purchaserShare":0.1,"functionDays":14,"utility":0.03,"delay":0.25,"discount":0.03,"netCash":100,"baseline":25000,"earnerShare":0,"annualNetWork":3000,"clinicalOverlapShare":0,"homeAllocation":0,"homeCost":5000,"homeCompletion":0.8,"homeUnmetShare":0.8,"homeIndependent":1,"homeUtility":0.02,"homeYears":2,"homeDelay":0.5,"assignment":1,"healthCA":1,"incomeCA":1,"burdenCA":1,"fee":0,"inducedHouseholds":0,"inducedLoss":0,"independentHealthHarm":0,"externalPerAttempt":100}
Historical alpha central — diagnostic only: Cost: $100K; California health QALYs: 0.02; all-population health QALYs: 0.02. Income-equivalent healthy years: 0.00. {"f":0.1,"w":34,"b":1.35,"h":4,"p":100,"o":1.5881269038170636,"m":0.5,"s":0.8,"a":0.5,"days":14,"u":0.1,"g":1,"cost":450.3927899225193,"N":4.440568421053229,"q":0.003804767458486105,"Q":0.016895330225604348,"price":59187952.33043336,"L":0.25}; r=0.03. All nonfinancial pathway inputs are judgments; not empirical bounds.
Counterfactual: CIL's existing grants, payroll and inventory, insured/vendor service, publicly financed device loan centers, Easy Does It emergency repair and individual backups continue. A donor-funded slot must actually accelerate restoration relative to these options. CIL's current month-long response queue is NOT itself the number of functional days lost or saved.
Attribution: m discounts replacement of grant/reserve funding or staffing constraints; a separately discounts equivalent alternative repair/loaner service and usable backups. s accounts for failed or unsuitable delivery. Do not count one disability-related utility improvement separately as avoided injury, isolation and mobility restoration. No attribution of all recipient work to the repair branch.
Conditional partial planning estimate, not measured CIL outcomes, a comprehensive organization estimate, a lower bound or a verified donor capacity offer. Revised temporary utility .03, purchaser share .1, net cash100 and resource baseline25000 are explicit judgments. Original auditor findings/remediation are still unverified. Other independent-living benefits and third-party costs may materially change the total.
Sensitivity
- Zero savings: $19.7M per DALY.
- Utility .10 with central savings: $5.4M; utility .01: $29.0M.
- Household resources $50K/$100K: $16.8M/$18.2M.
- Funding, completion or portfolio nulls remove successful additional outcomes; independently induced burdens can remain negative.
- Home-modification and paid-work cases are separate conditional diagnostics, not confidence limits or verified offers.
Unresolved inputs
- Actual marginal allocation to repair/loaner capacity and costed staffing plan.
- Hours, materials, completed repairs/loaners, device fit and unique client follow-up.
- Unfunded versus already-financed demand and whether money or skilled labor/inventory is limiting.
- Counterfactual functional days without CIL, alternative providers, backups and measured utility.
- Separate nonoverlapping home-access, institutional transition, Living Well and advocacy effects; these may dominate the partial model.
- Marginal third-party resource cost and current audit/control remediation evidence.
Health and income breakdown
For the modeled $100K: 0.01 health QALYs + 0.00 income-equivalent healthy years in California: $14.6M per DALY. Income equivalents are welfare comparisons, not observed QALYs or DALYs.
5. Funding and previous grants
Original returns report full-recipient expenses of $2,986,495 (FY2023), $3,662,458 (FY2024) and $4,370,584 (FY2025), all June-ending twelve-month periods. The three-year mean is $3,673,179. FY2024 functions were $3,017,406 program, $644,978 management and $74 fundraising. Original FY2024 Form 990 with FY2023 comparative totals
FY2025 expenses split into $2,752,037 program, $1,362,449 management and $256,098 fundraising. Revenue was $3,996,267, including $3,223,822 government grants and $349,468 other contributions. Compensation and benefits totaled $3,219,987. The operating deficit was $374,317; net assets were $7,809,089, of which $2,385,204 carried donor restrictions. Net assets are not all immediately available cash. Functional allocations changed substantially; they are accounting categories, not measures of effectiveness. Original FY2025 Form 990, IRS electronic filing
CIL says services are free and supported by government, foundations and individuals. Publicly funded Berkeley modifications, insured equipment alternatives and other donors all matter to substitution. A reported funding gap outside Berkeley is promising but does not price the ordinary-gift margin. The general donation page supports the broad portfolio and includes optional designated routes; this report assumes no designation and records no actual donation. Eligibility, free services and funding General donation route
CIL's current careers page posts a $28/hour starting-pay floor and benefits, while the AT page seeks skilled repair and preparation volunteers. These support a labor-capacity pathway but do not prove that cash is the binding constraint or that a donation funds a new position.
September 30 review checked all three original returns and confirmed the $3,673,179 mean. Original FY2023 return reports $2,132,657 program, $757,676 management and $96,162 fundraising. Total/program ratios are 1.400, 1.214 and 1.588 for FY2023–2025. FY2024's miscellaneous/indirect line allocates $325,124 to program and negative $302,724 to management. These accounting allocations require explanation before treating the ratio as a marginal repair cost; they are not evidence of misconduct. Included noncash contributions were $67,154, $68,766 and $67,668: avoid counting recognized resources twice. Full incremental donated-device, volunteer and partner costs remain unknown.
Annual expenses
Organization-level spending, including programs, administration and fundraising. The research list averages three comparable, consecutive full fiscal years when available.
- FY 2023: $3.0M; Center for Independent Living, EIN 23-7175191, 12-month period, Accrual Form 990 total functional expenses; year ended June 30. Source
- FY 2024: $3.7M; Center for Independent Living, EIN 23-7175191, 12-month period, Accrual Form 990 total functional expenses; year ended June 30. Source
- FY 2025: $4.4M; Center for Independent Living, EIN 23-7175191, 12-month period, Accrual Form 990 total functional expenses; year ended June 30. Source
6. Sources
- Current programs and Northern Alameda County service area. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Eligibility, free services and funding. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Assistive technology loaners and repairs. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Residential access and geographic funding gap. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Personal attendant services and limited provider registry. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Living Well Senior Program. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- General donation route. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Original FY2025 Form 990, IRS electronic filing. Center for Independent Living / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Original FY2024 Form 990 with FY2023 comparative totals. Center for Independent Living / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Filing and audit index. ProPublica / IRS and Federal Audit Clearinghouse. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Wheelchair repairs: delays, causes and associated outcomes. Wheelchair repair investigators, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. Published: 2024-10-18; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Factors influencing wheelchair repairs and consequences. Worobey and colleagues, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. Published: 2021-04-09; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Health promotion: evaluation of Living Well with a Disability. Ravesloot and colleagues, Health Education Research. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Living Well with a Disability: intervention and follow-up synthesis. Ravesloot and colleagues, CDC MMWR. Published: 2016-02-12; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- HIPI home modification cluster-randomized trial. Keall and colleagues, The Lancet. Published: 2015-01-17; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Assistive Technology: current queue, non-emergency scope and volunteer needs. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Current careers pay and benefits. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Community Independent Living Specialist vacancy. Center for Independent Living / Gusto. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Wheelchair Repairs: Delays, Causes, and Associated Outcomes — author institution abstract. Worobey et al. / University of Minnesota. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Draft PY2024 / FY2025 Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report. City of Berkeley. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- FY2025 Form 990 Schedule O. Center for Independent Living / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-13.
- Original FY2023 Form 990. Center for Independent Living / IRS. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-30.
- Whill sales and demonstrations. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-30.
- FY2025 audit listing; report not retrieved. ProPublica / Federal Audit Clearinghouse. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-09-30.
- Cost-effectiveness: comparing income and health. Coefficient Giving. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-02.
- Benefits counseling. Center for Independent Living. Published: not stated; retrieved: 2026-10-02.