{"edition":"new-york-city","organization":"St. Nicks Alliance","organizationId":"ein:51-0192170","boundaryVersion":"OMB-23-01-2023-07-21","updated":"2026-10-18","display":{"metric":{"id":"daly-equivalent","years":1,"label":"DALY","priceLabel":"$ / DALY"},"priceUSD":526930.1015509515,"canonicalPriceUSDPerTenEquivalentYears":5269301.015509515,"conversion":"display only; QALYs and income equivalents are not measured clinical DALYs"},"listDisplay":{"metric":{"id":"daly-equivalent","years":1,"label":"DALY","priceLabel":"$ / DALY"},"priceUSD":526930.1015509515,"canonicalPriceUSDPerTenEquivalentYears":5269301.015509515,"conversion":"display only; QALYs and income equivalents are not measured clinical DALYs"},"model":{"version":"st-nicks-nyc-beta-income-20261018","costScope":"CY2023 whole-organization expense divided by about 1,000 people placed per year; non-workforce programs charged but not credited.","geographicAttribution":"Brooklyn participants; 0.9 of earning years in the NYC metro.","formula":"Price = 10 × cost per placed participant ÷ Σ [0.5 × discounted years × ln(1 + 0.6 × gain ÷ base) × transfer × non-displacement × NYC share]. Health = 0.","counterfactual":"Randomized control applicants with access to other training and jobs.","attribution":"A gift is credited with the transferred average late effect per placed participant at whole-organization cost; other services unquantified.","uncertainty":"Dominated by whether the late single-site gain is real and transfers to current programs, and by the share of cost that is workforce.","nativeOutcomes":"Annual earnings and share earning $45,000+ over ten years.","inputs":[{"name":"CY2023 total expense","value":47665555,"unit":"USD","basis":"observed","rationale":"Form 990.","sourceIds":["propublica"]},{"name":"Placed per year","value":1000,"unit":"people","basis":"observed","rationale":"\"Over 1,000\" placed in jobs or advanced education annually.","sourceIds":["sn-workforce"]},{"name":"Late gross gain","value":6000,"unit":"USD per year, years 8–10","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Year-10 +32% on a ~$30,000 base, lower in years 8–9.","sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr"]},{"name":"Base earnings","value":30000,"unit":"USD per year","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Control-group level not retrieved.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"Transfer to current programs","value":0.5,"unit":"share","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Tested track was environmental remediation; current programs are broader.","sourceIds":["sn-workforce"]},{"name":"Non-displacement","value":0.85,"unit":"share","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Some trade jobs taken from other applicants.","sourceIds":[]}],"missingInputs":["Year-by-year dollar impacts and control means at St. Nicks.","Workforce program cost and enrollment.","Whether added funding creates added trainees."],"scenarios":[{"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"id":"central","label":"Whole-organization cost per placed participant, late trial gains","costUSD":4766555.5,"assumptions":"CY2023 whole expense over about 1,000 adults placed or advanced each year; $6,000 gross gain in years 8-10 and half that for five more years; 0.5 transfer, 0.85 non-displacement, 0.9 NYC.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":3600,"years":3,"delayYears":7,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":0.5,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.425,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Randomized WorkAdvance gains at St. Nicks appeared in years 8-10, reaching +32% in year 10; credited as a $6,000 average gross gain over years 8-10, net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"Randomized control applicants with access to other training and jobs."},{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1800,"years":5,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":0.5,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.425,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Judgment that half the late gain persists for five unobserved years after year 10.","counterfactual":"As above; persistence is a hypothesis."}]},{"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"id":"workforce-share-cost","label":"Only a quarter of spending is workforce","costUSD":1191638.875,"assumptions":"If a gift restricted to workforce programs bore only their share of cost (judgment: 25% of the budget).","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":3600,"years":3,"delayYears":7,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":0.5,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.425,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Randomized WorkAdvance gains at St. Nicks appeared in years 8-10, reaching +32% in year 10; credited as a $6,000 average gross gain over years 8-10, net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"Randomized control applicants with access to other training and jobs."},{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1800,"years":5,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":0.5,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.425,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Judgment that half the late gain persists for five unobserved years after year 10.","counterfactual":"As above; persistence is a hypothesis."}]},{"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"id":"no-tail","label":"Gains end at year 10","costUSD":4766555.5,"assumptions":"No persistence after the observed window.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":3600,"years":3,"delayYears":7,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":0.5,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.425,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Randomized WorkAdvance gains at St. Nicks appeared in years 8-10, reaching +32% in year 10; credited as a $6,000 average gross gain over years 8-10, net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"Randomized control applicants with access to other training and jobs."}]},{"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"id":"year10-gain-throughout","label":"32% of base in years 8-10","costUSD":4766555.5,"assumptions":"Uses the year-10 gain for all three late years.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":5760,"years":3,"delayYears":7,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":0.5,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.425,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Randomized WorkAdvance gains at St. Nicks appeared in years 8-10, reaching +32% in year 10; credited as a $6,000 average gross gain over years 8-10, net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"Randomized control applicants with access to other training and jobs."},{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1800,"years":5,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":0.5,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.425,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Judgment that half the late gain persists for five unobserved years after year 10.","counterfactual":"As above; persistence is a hypothesis."}]},{"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"id":"full-transfer","label":"Current programs as effective as WorkAdvance","costUSD":4766555.5,"assumptions":"The trial model applies to today’s broader trades and youth programs.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":3600,"years":3,"delayYears":7,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":1,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.85,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Randomized WorkAdvance gains at St. Nicks appeared in years 8-10, reaching +32% in year 10; credited as a $6,000 average gross gain over years 8-10, net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"Randomized control applicants with access to other training and jobs."},{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1800,"years":5,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":1,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.85,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Judgment that half the late gain persists for five unobserved years after year 10.","counterfactual":"As above; persistence is a hypothesis."}]},{"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"id":"low-transfer","label":"Current programs much less effective","costUSD":4766555.5,"assumptions":"Only a small part of current workforce activity resembles the tested model.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":3600,"years":3,"delayYears":7,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":0.25,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.2125,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Randomized WorkAdvance gains at St. Nicks appeared in years 8-10, reaching +32% in year 10; credited as a $6,000 average gross gain over years 8-10, net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"Randomized control applicants with access to other training and jobs."},{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1800,"years":5,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.9,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"transferToCurrentProgram":0.25,"nonDisplacement":0.85},"causalShare":0.2125,"sourceIds":["mdrc-10yr","clear-7yr"],"rationale":"Judgment that half the late gain persists for five unobserved years after year 10.","counterfactual":"As above; persistence is a hypothesis."}]},{"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"id":"no-effect","label":"No effect at current scale","costUSD":4766555.5,"assumptions":"Late gains do not replicate.","incomePathways":[]}],"sensitivity":[{"id":"workforce-share-cost","label":"Only a quarter of spending is workforce","pricePer10":1317325.2538773788,"assumptions":"If a gift restricted to workforce programs bore only their share of cost (judgment: 25% of the budget)."},{"id":"no-tail","label":"Gains end at year 10","pricePer10":9283536.033775803,"assumptions":"No persistence after the observed window."},{"id":"year10-gain-throughout","label":"32% of base in years 8-10","pricePer10":4016103.0188264474,"assumptions":"Uses the year-10 gain for all three late years."},{"id":"full-transfer","label":"Current programs as effective as WorkAdvance","pricePer10":2634650.5077547575,"assumptions":"The trial model applies to today’s broader trades and youth programs."},{"id":"low-transfer","label":"Current programs much less effective","pricePer10":10538602.03101903,"assumptions":"Only a small part of current workforce activity resembles the tested model."},{"id":"no-effect","label":"No effect at current scale","assumptions":"Late gains do not replicate."}]},"sources":[{"id":"mdrc-10yr","title":"Effects of Sector-Focused Training After 10 Years: Findings from the WorkAdvance Evaluation","publisher":"MDRC (Yusim, Schaberg, Tessler and Ubalijoro)","url":"https://www.mdrc.org/work/publications/effects-sector-focused-training-after-10-years","published":"2025-09-01","retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"clear-7yr","title":"Employment and earnings effects of the WorkAdvance demonstration after seven years (St. Nicks site)","publisher":"U.S. Department of Labor CLEAR","url":"https://clear.dol.gov/Study/Employment-and-earnings-effects-WorkAdvance-demonstration-after-seven-years-Kanengiser-et-0","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"clear-3yr","title":"Can sector strategies promote longer-term effects? Three-year impacts (St. Nicks site)","publisher":"U.S. Department of Labor CLEAR","url":"https://clear.dol.gov/Study/Can-sector-strategies-promote-longer-term-effects-Three-year-impacts-WorkAdvance-0","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"sn-workforce","title":"Workforce Development","publisher":"St. Nicks Alliance","url":"https://stnicksalliance.org/workforce-development/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"propublica","title":"St Nicks Alliance Corp, Form 990 filings (EIN 51-0192170)","publisher":"IRS, hosted by ProPublica","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/510192170","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"income-cg","title":"Cost-effectiveness: health and log-income comparison","publisher":"Coefficient Giving","url":"https://coefficientgiving.org/research/cost-effectiveness/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"}]}