{"edition":"chicago","organization":"Saga Education","organizationId":"ein:47-2168942","boundaryVersion":"OMB-23-01-2023-07-21","updated":"2026-10-18","display":{"metric":{"id":"daly-equivalent","years":1,"label":"DALY","priceLabel":"$ / DALY"},"priceUSD":101578.79715650817,"canonicalPriceUSDPerTenEquivalentYears":1015787.9715650817,"conversion":"display only; QALYs and income equivalents are not measured clinical DALYs"},"listDisplay":{"metric":{"id":"daly-equivalent","years":1,"label":"DALY","priceLabel":"$ / DALY"},"priceUSD":101578.79715650817,"canonicalPriceUSDPerTenEquivalentYears":1015787.9715650817,"conversion":"display only; QALYs and income equivalents are not measured clinical DALYs"},"model":{"version":"saga-chicago-beta-income-20261018b","costScope":"FY2025 whole-organization expense divided by 2024–25 Direct students plus Widespread students at one-tenth weight.","geographicAttribution":"Chicago Direct students; 0.8 of adult earning years assumed lived in the Chicago metro.","formula":"Price = 10 × cost per student ÷ [0.5 × discounted years(ages 25–59, from 15) × ln(1 + net gain ÷ base) × causal × transfer × non-displacement × Chicago share]. Gross gain = 0.22 SD × 37.5 percentiles/SD × $150 × CPI. Health = 0.","counterfactual":"Randomized control students on the regular CPS schedule, often double-dose Algebra.","attribution":"A gift is credited with the transferred average effect of an added Direct student at whole-organization average cost; whether a gift adds a Chicago student is unverified.","uncertainty":"Dominated by the causal link from test scores to adult earnings, then by current cost per student, transfer to today’s program and out-migration.","nativeOutcomes":"Math test scores, math grades and course failures in grades 9–11; imprecise graduation; no adult outcomes.","inputs":[{"name":"FY2025 total expense","value":25426248,"unit":"USD","basis":"observed","rationale":"Form 990, fiscal year ending June 2025.","sourceIds":["propublica"]},{"name":"Direct students 2024–25","value":3083,"unit":"students","basis":"observed","rationale":"Annual report; same fiscal year as the expense.","sourceIds":["saga-annual","saga-annual-2025"]},{"name":"Widespread students 2024–25","value":15000,"unit":"students","basis":"observed","rationale":"Over 15,000 students reached through district-employed tutors.","sourceIds":["saga-annual-2025"]},{"name":"Widespread cost weight","value":0.1,"unit":"Direct-student equivalents","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Training and support of district tutors costs far less per student than Saga-employed daily tutoring.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"Published cost per student (2020)","value":3100,"unit":"USD","basis":"observed","rationale":"Co-founder statement.","sourceIds":["hechinger-2020"]},{"name":"Trial cost per participant","value":3800,"unit":"USD","basis":"observed","rationale":"Authors’ best estimate for 2013–15.","sourceIds":["saga-wp"]},{"name":"Persistent math effect","value":0.22,"unit":"SD","basis":"observed","rationale":"Pooled treatment-on-treated effect in 11th grade.","sourceIds":["saga-wp"]},{"name":"Percentiles per SD","value":37.5,"unit":"percentiles per SD","basis":"observed","rationale":"Study 1: 0.16 SD equals 6 percentile points.","sourceIds":["saga-wp"]},{"name":"Earnings per percentile","value":150,"unit":"USD per year at age 27","basis":"observed","rationale":"Chetty et al. (2011) association as cited by the trial authors.","sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"]},{"name":"CPI adjustments","value":[1.47,1.37],"unit":"ratio","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Approximate CPI-U changes.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"Causal share of score-earnings link","value":0.5,"unit":"share","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Quasi-experimental teacher value-added implies about half of this mapping; fadeout meta-analyses find weak, non-robust links.","sourceIds":["saga-wp","cfr-review","fadeout"]},{"name":"Transfer to current program","value":0.6,"unit":"share","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Chicago Direct students now average about 70 hours vs roughly 120 in the daily trial model; later lower-cost trials found 0.19–0.23 SD.","sourceIds":["saga-tech-rct","saga-tech","saga-annual-2025","saga-wp"]},{"name":"Non-displacement","value":0.9,"unit":"share","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Skill gains are mostly not zero-sum.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"Chicago share of adult years","value":0.8,"unit":"share","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Allows for moving away.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"Net welfare share","value":0.6,"unit":"share","basis":"judgment","rationale":"After income and payroll taxes and lost means-tested benefits.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"Adult base income","value":35000,"unit":"USD per year","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Reference personal income for adults from these schools.","sourceIds":[]}],"scenarios":[{"id":"central","label":"Allocated FY2025 cost per Direct student, causal half of the score-earnings link","costUSD":554794.8505345843,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"FY2025 total expense over 2024-25 Direct students plus Widespread students at 0.1 weight; persistent 0.22 SD gain; half the Chetty association treated as causal; 0.6 transfer for lower current dose; 0.9 non-displacement; 0.8 Chicago residence; 60% net welfare.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.6,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.27,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"whole-cost-to-direct","label":"Whole FY2025 expense charged to Direct students","costUSD":824724.2296464483,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"All Widespread and technology work treated as overhead of the Direct program.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.6,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.27,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"cofounder-cost","label":"Published per-student cost","costUSD":387500,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"Co-founder’s $3,100 per student (2020), inflated to 2025.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.6,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.27,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"trial-dose-transfer","label":"Current program as effective as the trials","costUSD":554794.8505345843,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"Prior review’s transfer factor; ignores the lower current dose.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.8,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.36000000000000004,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"research-cost","label":"Program cost as measured in the trials","costUSD":520600,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"Central benefits at the authors’ $3,800 per-student cost, inflated to 2025.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.6,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.27,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"previous-review-20261018","label":"First in-depth review, 18 October 2026 (superseded)","costUSD":881770.7427830035,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"FY2023 expense over 2024-25 Direct students with 0.8 transfer; retained for comparison.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.8,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.36000000000000004,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"full-association","label":"Full score-earnings association is causal","costUSD":554794.8505345843,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"As the trial authors assume.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":1,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.6,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.54,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"quarter-association","label":"Only a quarter of the association is causal","costUSD":554794.8505345843,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"Stronger fade-out or weaker causal link from test scores to earnings.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.25,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.6,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.135,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"study1-only","label":"Smaller study-1 immediate effect only","costUSD":554794.8505345843,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"Uses 0.16 SD instead of the pooled persistent 0.22 SD.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":793.8,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.6,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.27,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"low-transfer","label":"Current program much less effective than the trials","costUSD":554794.8505345843,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"Scale-up or implementation drift halves the transferred effect.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.3,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.135,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"all-local","label":"All adult years in the Chicago metro","costUSD":554794.8505345843,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"No out-migration discount.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.03,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.6,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.27,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"discount-5pct","label":"5% discount rate","costUSD":554794.8505345843,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"As in the authors’ benefit-cost calculation.","incomePathways":[{"people":100,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":35000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":1091.475,"years":35,"delayYears":10,"discountRate":0.05,"editionShare":0.8,"independentShare":1,"causalFactors":{"causalScoreToEarnings":0.5,"transferToCurrentProgram":0.6,"nonDisplacement":0.9},"causalShare":0.27,"sourceIds":["saga-wp","chetty-2011"],"rationale":"Persistent randomized math gain (0.22 SD in 11th grade) mapped to adult earnings with the Chetty et al. percentile association the trial authors use, then discounted for causality, transfer and displacement; net of taxes and lost benefits.","counterfactual":"The randomized control group received the regular CPS schedule (often double-dose Algebra); the effect is net of that alternative."}]},{"id":"no-earnings-effect","label":"Test-score gains do not change adult earnings","costUSD":554794.8505345843,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"Full fade-out of any earnings effect.","incomePathways":[]}],"sensitivity":[{"id":"whole-cost-to-direct","label":"Whole FY2025 expense charged to Direct students","pricePer10":1510008.5221157216,"assumptions":"All Widespread and technology work treated as overhead of the Direct program."},{"id":"cofounder-cost","label":"Published per-student cost","pricePer10":709483.5840711038,"assumptions":"Co-founder’s $3,100 per student (2020), inflated to 2025."},{"id":"trial-dose-transfer","label":"Current program as effective as the trials","pricePer10":761840.9786738114,"assumptions":"Prior review’s transfer factor; ignores the lower current dose."},{"id":"research-cost","label":"Program cost as measured in the trials","pricePer10":953179.7519159139,"assumptions":"Central benefits at the authors’ $3,800 per-student cost, inflated to 2025."},{"id":"previous-review-20261018","label":"First in-depth review, 18 October 2026 (superseded)","pricePer10":1210842.3230684996,"assumptions":"FY2023 expense over 2024-25 Direct students with 0.8 transfer; retained for comparison."},{"id":"full-association","label":"Full score-earnings association is causal","pricePer10":507893.98578254087,"assumptions":"As the trial authors assume."},{"id":"quarter-association","label":"Only a quarter of the association is causal","pricePer10":2031575.9431301635,"assumptions":"Stronger fade-out or weaker causal link from test scores to earnings."},{"id":"study1-only","label":"Smaller study-1 immediate effect only","pricePer10":1390911.1504661755,"assumptions":"Uses 0.16 SD instead of the pooled persistent 0.22 SD."},{"id":"low-transfer","label":"Current program much less effective than the trials","pricePer10":2031575.9431301635,"assumptions":"Scale-up or implementation drift halves the transferred effect."},{"id":"all-local","label":"All adult years in the Chicago metro","pricePer10":812630.3772520655,"assumptions":"No out-migration discount."},{"id":"discount-5pct","label":"5% discount rate","pricePer10":1584864.098987555,"assumptions":"As in the authors’ benefit-cost calculation."},{"id":"no-earnings-effect","label":"Test-score gains do not change adult earnings","assumptions":"Full fade-out of any earnings effect."}],"missingInputs":["Chicago-only Direct students and cost per added student.","Any measured adult outcome (college, earnings) for trial participants.","Dose-response evidence linking tutoring hours to persistent gains."]},"sources":[{"id":"saga-wp","title":"Not Too Late: Improving Academic Outcomes Among Adolescents (IPR WP-21-12)","publisher":"Northwestern Institute for Policy Research","url":"https://www.ipr.northwestern.edu/documents/working-papers/2021/wp-21-12.pdf","published":"2021-03-08","retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"saga-nber","title":"Not Too Late: Improving Academic Outcomes Among Adolescents (NBER w28531)","publisher":"National Bureau of Economic Research","url":"https://ideas.repec.org/p/nbr/nberwo/28531.html","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"saga-summary","title":"Not too late: study summary","publisher":"Stanford National Student Support Accelerator","url":"https://nssa.stanford.edu/studies/not-too-late-improving-academic-outcomes-among-adolescents","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"saga-tech-rct","title":"An RCT of Saga Technology: high-dosage tutoring and an education technology platform for ninth graders","publisher":"Arnold Ventures","url":"https://arnoldventures.org/stories/a-randomized-controlled-trial-rct-of-saga-technology-providing-high-dosage-math-tutoring-and-engagement-with-an-education-technology-platform-to-ninth-graders-in-public-schools","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"chetty-2011","title":"How Does Your Kindergarten Classroom Affect Your Earnings? (as cited in the trial paper)","publisher":"Chetty et al., Quarterly Journal of Economics","url":"https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjr041","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"saga-annual","title":"Saga Education annual report 2024–25","publisher":"Saga Education","url":"https://saga.org/?p=994457","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"propublica","title":"Saga Innovations, Form 990 filings (EIN 47-2168942)","publisher":"IRS, hosted by ProPublica","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/472168942","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"saga-tech","title":"Can Technology Facilitate Scale? Evidence from a Randomized Evaluation of High-Dosage Tutoring (NBER w32510)","publisher":"University of Chicago Education Lab (Bhatt, Guryan et al.)","url":"https://educationlab.uchicago.edu/resources/nber-working-paper-can-technology-facilitate-scale-evidence-from-a-randomized-evaluation-of-high-dosage-tutoring","published":"2024-06-01","retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"saga-annual-2025","title":"Saga Education annual report 2024–25","publisher":"Saga Education","url":"https://saga.org/impact/2025-annual-report/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"hechinger-2020","title":"This math tutoring program gets blockbuster results in high-poverty schools","publisher":"The Hechinger Report","url":"https://hechingerreport.org/this-math-tutoring-program-gets-blockbuster-results-in-high-poverty-schools/","published":"2020-01-29","retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"cfr-review","title":"Review of Chetty, Friedman and Rockoff teacher value-added study","publisher":"National Education Policy Center","url":"https://nepc-archive.colorado.edu/sites/default/files/ttr-chetty-teachimpacts_0.pdf","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"fadeout","title":"Why Do Most Education Interventions Fade Out Over Time?","publisher":"Education Next (Bailey, Watts and Hart)","url":"https://www.educationnext.org/?p=49725386","published":"2026-02-12","retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"diploma-premium","title":"The Signaling Value of a High School Diploma","publisher":"RAND (Martorell and Clark)","url":"https://www.rand.org/pubs/working_papers/WR780.html","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"},{"id":"income-cg","title":"Cost-effectiveness: health and log-income comparison","publisher":"Coefficient Giving","url":"https://coefficientgiving.org/research/cost-effectiveness/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-18"}]}