{"edition":"california","organization":"California YIMBY Education Fund","organizationId":"ein:85-1438188","boundaryVersion":"US-CA-state-v1","updated":"2026-10-07","display":{"metric":{"id":"daly-equivalent","years":1,"label":"DALY","priceLabel":"$ / DALY"},"priceUSD":36936980.054223344,"canonicalPriceUSDPerTenEquivalentYears":369369800.5422334,"conversion":"display only; QALYs and income equivalents are not measured clinical DALYs"},"listDisplay":{"metric":{"id":"daly-equivalent","years":1,"label":"DALY","priceLabel":"$ / DALY"},"priceUSD":36936980.054223344,"canonicalPriceUSDPerTenEquivalentYears":369369800.5422334,"conversion":"display only; QALYs and income equivalents are not measured clinical DALYs"},"model":{"version":"ca-yimby-alpha-signed-resources-v3","costScope":"Three years of whole-recipient FY2024 accrual cost, including national MAP and support functions. Partial California housing-health estimate. Private construction, public infrastructure and unrecognized shared/volunteer resources not in central donor cost; sensitivity added. Household burden excludes reimbursed recipient/construction/infrastructure costs already priced. Rent savings are occupant incidence, not global net resource creation; disjoint landlord/public consumption and realconstructioncost alternatives expose scope.","geographicAttribution":"N explicitly counts net additional occupied California homes, not all national MAP output. u is total California resident health per net home-year and includes occupancy/displacement within its subjective value; no population or household multiplier. The home-year utility is an expected net health area across changing occupants and already includes survival, occupancy turnover and benefit fade by judgment; it is not a fixed utility promised to every initial resident for ten years.","formula":"C=3*E; U=N*p*a*b; A=sum_{t=3}^{12}(1+d)^(-t); Q_CA=U*A*u. P10=10*C/Q_CA. Only ten finite home-years; N net of replacement/displaced construction. Resource stress C'=C+U*500000. Other health remains unknown. Resource household-equivalents=U, no occupancy/clinicalutility multiplier. Joint renter-saving/non-saving netresources afterretention and positiveoverlap minusFULLburden; .5*people*A*log1p(net/baseline), years3–12 matchclinicalhorizon. Three-year100000gift changesE=100000/3 and reachproportionally.","counterfactual":"SB79 is operative, HCD and local governments have statutory duties, existing finance/building pipelines and other advocates continue. Credit only additional completed occupied homes beyond these and net of construction elsewhere, not all newly legal capacity.","attribution":"p incremental coalition implementation, a c3 Education Fund contribution distinct from c4/shared staff, b gift funding response; each once. Conditional N is before those factors, not a donor-attributable forecast.","uncertainty":"N, policy probabilities and health conversion are uncalibrated judgments. Large price range does not validate any particular yield. Financial relief and mobility trials do not establish health per market-rate home. Whole portfolio remains unpriced. Householduniqueequivalence, renter/owner mix, netprivatepayment reduction, retention, overlap and burden are unmeasured hypotheses. Nearby marketrents, productivejobs, ownerlandvalue and nationalMAPresource effects unknown.","nativeOutcomes":"Central 2.5 net additional occupied home-equivalents, 20.101335745065107 discounted California home-years, 0.20101335745065108 QALYs. Hypothetical outputs, not reported completions.","inputs":[{"name":"E","value":3047162,"unit":"USD/year recipient accrual expense","basis":"observed","rationale":"Original2024 return; no netted event/COGS costs.","sourceIds":["cay24"]},{"name":"N","value":1000,"unit":"conditional net additional occupied California homes","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Judgment of implementation scale, not existing permits or empirical pipeline.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"p","value":0.1,"unit":"incremental coalition implementation probability","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Beyond existing law/public duties over3-year support window.","sourceIds":["hcd-sb79"]},{"name":"a","value":0.1,"unit":"Education Fund c3 contribution","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Distinct from c4 and other partners; not equal-brand attribution.","sourceIds":["cay24r","cay-give"]},{"name":"b","value":0.25,"unit":"ordinary-funding response","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Reserve, substitution and capacity judgment.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"u","value":0.01,"unit":"QALY/net occupied home-year","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Judgment across all affected residents; no extra occupancy multiplier, no rent-to-health conversion.","sourceIds":["mto","income-health"]},{"name":"d","value":0.03,"unit":"annual discount rate","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Ten benefit years, years3–12 only.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"A","value":8.040534298026042,"unit":"discounted home-years/home","basis":"judgment","rationale":"Arithmetic finite horizon sum years3–12.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"Q_other_CA","value":null,"unit":"California QALYs","basis":"unknown","rationale":"Other policy, transport and national effects not priced.","sourceIds":[]},{"name":"resource-saverShare","value":0.5,"unit":"coefficient","basis":"judgment","sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give"],"rationale":"Illustrativejoint household incidence, not observed rent saving or marginalhousing forecast."},{"name":"resource-savings","value":1200,"unit":"USD","basis":"judgment","sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give"],"rationale":"Illustrativejoint household incidence, not observed rent saving or marginalhousing forecast."},{"name":"resource-netRetained","value":0.8,"unit":"coefficient","basis":"judgment","sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give"],"rationale":"Illustrativejoint household incidence, not observed rent saving or marginalhousing forecast."},{"name":"resource-positiveShare","value":0.5,"unit":"coefficient","basis":"judgment","sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give"],"rationale":"Illustrativejoint household incidence, not observed rent saving or marginalhousing forecast."},{"name":"resource-burden","value":100,"unit":"USD","basis":"judgment","sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give"],"rationale":"Illustrativejoint household incidence, not observed rent saving or marginalhousing forecast."},{"name":"resource-before","value":30000,"unit":"USD","basis":"judgment","sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give"],"rationale":"Illustrativejoint household incidence, not observed rent saving or marginalhousing forecast."}],"scenarios":[{"id":"alpha-central-diagnostic","label":"Original health-only diagnostic: Conditional California net-home health","costUSD":9141486,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"N=1000;p=.1;a=.1;b=.25;u=.01;d=.03;years3–12."},{"id":"original-low","label":"Original health-only diagnostic: Weak implementation and health","costUSD":9141486,"allPopulationQalys":0.000048243205788156256,"editionQalys":0.000048243205788156256,"assumptions":"N=100;p=.02;a=.03;b=.1;u=.001;timing central."},{"id":"original-high","label":"Original health-only diagnostic: Favorable finite housing influence","costUSD":9141486,"allPopulationQalys":60.304007235195314,"editionQalys":60.304007235195314,"assumptions":"N=10000;p=.3;a=.25;b=.5;u=.02;timing central."},{"id":"original-zero","label":"Original health-only diagnostic: No added net homes or health","costUSD":9141486,"allPopulationQalys":0,"editionQalys":0,"assumptions":"No net additional construction or health effect."},{"id":"original-adverse","label":"Original health-only diagnostic: Net adverse stress","costUSD":9141486,"allPopulationQalys":-1,"editionQalys":-1,"assumptions":"One California QALY lost via displacement, harmful location or opportunity costs; judgment."},{"id":"original-portfolio","label":"Original health-only diagnostic: Complete portfolio unknown","costUSD":9141486,"allPopulationQalys":null,"editionQalys":null,"assumptions":"Other effects unpriced."},{"id":"original-construction-resources","label":"Original health-only diagnostic: Add attributable construction resource stress","costUSD":10391486,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"2.5 net home-equivalents*$500000; same health, not a market quote."},{"id":"central","label":"central","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":380,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."}]},{"id":"financial-null","label":"financial-null","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":0,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":0,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":0,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":0,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."}]},{"id":"clinical-null-financial-only","label":"clinical-null-financial-only","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0,"allPopulationQalys":0,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":380,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."}]},{"id":"income-unknown","label":"income-unknown","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomeUnknown":true},{"id":"no-capacity","label":"no-capacity","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0,"allPopulationQalys":0,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[]},{"id":"no-implementation","label":"no-implementation","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0,"allPopulationQalys":0,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[]},{"id":"no-rent-saving","label":"no-rent-saving","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":0,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."}]},{"id":"adverse-commute-cost","label":"adverse-commute-cost","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":1000,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-520,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-1000,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."}]},{"id":"no-clinical-response","label":"no-clinical-response","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0,"allPopulationQalys":0,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":380,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."}]},{"id":"positive-overlap-zero","label":"positive-overlap-zero","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."}]},{"id":"disjoint-landlord-consumption","label":"disjoint-landlord-consumption","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":1.25,\"payerLoss\":1200,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":380,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":50000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-1200,"rationale":"Hypotheticaldisjointowner/landlord orpublicpayer consumptionloss; fullnegativeincidence, notduplicate realcapitalcost."}]},{"id":"disjoint-public-consumption","label":"disjoint-public-consumption","costUSD":9141486,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":1,\"payerLoss\":100,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":380,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":50000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaldisjointowner/landlord orpublicpayer consumptionloss; fullnegativeincidence, notduplicate realcapitalcost."}]},{"id":"additional-construction-resources","label":"additional-construction-resources","costUSD":10391486,"editionQalys":0.20101335745065108,"allPopulationQalys":0.20101335745065108,"assumptions":"{\"E\":3047162,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":1250000}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":380,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":1.25,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."}]},{"id":"gift-100000-three-year-window","label":"gift-100000-three-year-window","costUSD":100000,"editionQalys":0.0021989133654052645,"allPopulationQalys":0.0021989133654052645,"assumptions":"{\"E\":33333.333333333336,\"N\":1000,\"p\":0.1,\"a\":0.1,\"b\":0.25,\"u\":0.01,\"d\":0.03,\"years\":10,\"delay\":3,\"saverShare\":0.5,\"savings\":1200,\"netRetained\":0.8,\"positiveShare\":0.5,\"burden\":100,\"before\":30000,\"payerPeople\":0,\"payerLoss\":0,\"payerBefore\":50000,\"externalCost\":0}; conditional household incidence/dollars, not measured rents or causal donation return.","incomePathways":[{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":0.013673925661539056,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":380,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."},{"years":10,"delayYears":3,"discountRate":0.03,"causalShare":1,"editionShare":1,"independentShare":1,"sourceIds":["fees24","cay-give","hcd-sb79"],"counterfactual":"Existing operative law, public implementation, constructionfinance/pipeline andc4/otheradvocates continue. Netoccupiedhomeproxyincludesimplementation,c3contribution andfundingonce; householdresources do notdependclinicalutility.","people":0.013673925661539056,"annualIncomeBeforeUSD":30000,"annualIncomeGainUSD":-100,"rationale":"Hypotheticaljoint renter-saving/non-saving household resources: actualrent/payment/commute spendchange aftertax/benefitretention/positiveoverlap minusFULLdisjointhouseholdburden. Notassetvalue,grosssalary orretailhousingvalue."}]}],"sensitivity":["Central $454770076.7718504/10 California QALYs. $500000 per net home resource stress adds $1250000.","If new supply mostly reallocates already adequately housed residents without health improvement, u can be zero.","Unit construction/resource cost is not a net social cost; benefits, capital residual value and opportunity costs require separate accounting.","No synthetic historical mean across cash/accrual years."],"missingInputs":["c3-specific gift-sensitive implementation plan and net completion yield.","Coalition/c3 attribution versus public baseline and c4 resources.","California occupant outcomes, counterfactual housing and net crowding/stability effects.","Full construction/infrastructure resource costs, unrecognized shared resources and omitted portfolio effects.","Unique occupant households/turnover, genuine netrent/commute/pay changes aftertax/benefits; landlord/publicpayer incidence and realcapital opportunitycost; gift-specific implementednetcompletedhomes."]},"sources":[{"id":"cay24","title":"2024 Form 990","publisher":"California YIMBY Education Fund / IRS","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/851438188/202523219349314572/full","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"cay23","title":"2023 Form 990","publisher":"California YIMBY Education Fund / IRS","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/851438188/202403189349309890/full","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"cay22","title":"2022 Form 990","publisher":"California YIMBY Education Fund / IRS","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/851438188/202410339349301631/full","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"cay24r","title":"2024 Form 990 Schedule R: related organization and shared employees","publisher":"California YIMBY Education Fund / IRS","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202523219349314572/IRS990ScheduleR","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"cay24d","title":"2024 Form 990 Schedule D: related-party liability","publisher":"California YIMBY Education Fund / IRS","url":"https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/full_text/202523219349314572/IRS990ScheduleD","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"cay-give","title":"Ways to Give: distinct c3, c4 and PAC recipients","publisher":"California YIMBY","url":"https://cayimby.org/waystogive/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-10-07"},{"id":"map-about","title":"About the Metropolitan Abundance Project","publisher":"Metropolitan Abundance Project","url":"https://www.metroabundance.org/about-us/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"map-give","title":"MAP donation page identifies Education Fund fiscal recipient","publisher":"Metropolitan Abundance Project","url":"https://www.metroabundance.org/donate/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"cay-reports","title":"Research reports from the Education Fund","publisher":"California YIMBY Education Fund","url":"https://cayimby.org/reports/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"adu24","title":"California ADU Reform: A Retrospective","publisher":"California YIMBY Education Fund / Nolan Gray","url":"https://cayimby.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/CAY-ADU_Report-2024-v4.pdf","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"fees24","title":"The Impact of Fees: Rethinking Local Revenues for More Multifamily Housing","publisher":"California YIMBY Education Fund","url":"https://cayimby.org/reports/the-impact-of-fees/","published":"2024-06-13","retrieved":"2026-10-07"},{"id":"hcd-sb79","title":"SB79 Transit-Oriented Development, updated August19,2026","publisher":"California Department of Housing and Community Development","url":"https://www.hcd.ca.gov/planning-and-research/sb79-tod","published":"2026-08-19","retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"sb9-outcomes","title":"California's HOME Act Turns One: Data and Insights from the First Year of Senate Bill9","publisher":"Terner Center / David Garcia and Muhammad Alameldin","url":"https://ternercenter.berkeley.edu/research-and-policy/sb-9-turns-one-applications/","published":"2023-01-18","retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"supply","title":"Supply Shock Versus Demand Shock: The Local Effects of New Housing in Low-Income Areas","publisher":"Asquith, Mast and Reed / Upjohn Institute","url":"https://research.upjohn.org/up_workingpapers/316/","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"mto","title":"Long-Term Neighborhood Effects on Low-Income Families: Evidence from Moving to Opportunity","publisher":"Ludwig and colleagues / NBER","url":"https://www.nber.org/papers/w18772","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"},{"id":"income-health","title":"Does Income Affect Health? Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial of a Guaranteed Income, revised August2026","publisher":"Miller and colleagues / NBER","url":"https://www.nber.org/papers/w32711","published":null,"retrieved":"2026-09-14"}]}